Students and their families have enjoyed rights of privacy and access in regard to school records ever since 1974, under a law sponsored by conservative stalwart Senator James Buckley. The Family Education Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) prevents the unauthorized release of student records and also ensures parental access.
FERPA is administered by the Family Policy Compliance Office (FPCO) of the Department of Education. Over the 27 years of this law's existence, students, parents and schools have been generally well satisfied with FPCO's enforcement.
FERPA has grown in significance over the years. When public schools have denied families access to their children's records, FPCO has ordered the schools to comply with FERPA and allow parental and student access. FERPA guarded against the release (for political purposes) of the education records of Dan Quayle, Bill Clinton, and Supreme Court nominees.
The U.S. Supreme Court is now reviewing FERPA for the first time. On appeal is a decision by the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. The case involves an Oklahoma public school where students were grading each other's papers. Falvo v. Owasso Indep. School Dist., No. 99-5130.
The school required students to give their classwork to classmates for peer grading. Upon return of the grade assigned by a fellow student, each student was then required to read his grade aloud for transcription by the teacher.
Parent Kristja Falvo, along with three children in the school district, objected to this practice based on grading errors and embarrassment. Predictably, the public school ignored the parental complaint and continued its peer grading practice, although it did subsequently allow silent reporting of the grades.
The parent sued. The school's defenders insist that many common school practices, from publishing an honor roll to selecting first chairs in the orchestra, would end if the parent were to prevail. The District court held in favor of the school.
On appeal, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed and ruled in favor of the parent. The Court did not impose liability on the school, but ordered it to terminate peer grading for children of parents who object.
The Tenth Circuit thus expanded FERPA by protecting families even in this relatively harmless situation. Under this holding, teachers cannot require a student to give his work to another student for grading if his family objects to the practice.
The Court held that "Congress intended FERPA to preclude a teacher from revealing to one student the grades of another when written in a grade book." Therefore, the Court reasoned, "it would be incongruous to permit a teacher to disclose or allow the dissemination of those grades to other students immediately before recording them in the grade book. . . ."
This ruling went somewhat beyond FPCO's own precedents, which allows schools to utilize peer grading under certain limited circumstances. The Supreme Court, in taking this case, may feel that the Tenth Circuit expanded FERPA too far.
But FERPA protects family rights and, thus, an expansive interpretation is much preferable to a narrow view limiting parental rights, which is sought by the public school system and by the Justice Department. Because of mandatory school attendance laws, families need FERPA to guard against improper behavior by school officials.
The Justice Department's brief filed in the Falvo case and the Anti-Terrorism bill that Attorney General John Ashcroft is lobbying Congress to pass both argue for severely limiting the effectiveness of FERPA. It is difficult to understand why the Bush Justice Department is taking this position against parents and for increased government control.