If you've ever attended or watched a Republican or Democratic National Convention, you've seen the tension, the emotion, and the bedlam. Now imagine holding the Republican and Democratic National Conventions together - at the same time, and in the same hall. Imagine the confrontations of partisan politicians and pressure groups, the clash of liberals and conservatives, and the tirades of the activists - all demanding that their view of constitutional change prevail. Imagine the gridlock as the Jesse Helms caucus tries to work out a constitutional change with the Jesse Jackson caucus!
That's what it would be like if the United States ever called a new Constitutional Convention for the first time in more than two centuries. It would be a self-inflicted wound that could do permanent damage to our nation and to our process of self-government, and possibly even to our liberty.
The most influential players in a new Constitutional Convention would be Big Media, trying to predict or even dictate the changes. The demonstrators would hold court outside the convention hall, with TV cameras giving us on-the-spot coverage of pressure groups and radicals demanding constitutional changes. The original Constitutional Convention of 1787 deliberated in complete secrecy and there were no leaks to the press. That is obviously impossible today.
Nobody can predict what the rules or the agenda of a new Constitutional Convention would be. There is nothing in the Constitution or in any law to guide us. Constitutional authorities, both conservative and liberal, say it is impossible for Congress or anyone else to limit the agenda. A national convention would throw confusion, uncertainty, and court cases around our governmental process and make us look foolish in the eyes of the world.
There is no public support across America for a new Constitutional Convention. Yet, several pressure groups have tried for years to invoke Article V of the U.S. Constitution in an attempt to plunge America into a Constitutional Convention.
The latest effort was a lawsuit filed by plaintiff Bill Walker to get the U.S. District Court of the Western District of Washington at Seattle to order Congress to call a Constitutional Convention because more than two-thirds of the states, over many decades, have passed resolutions calling for a Convention, even though those resolutions were all for different single-issue purposes. On March 19, 2001, in Walker v. United States, the Court dismissed the suit because the plaintiff didn't have standing and because the issue is a political question that is properly within the province of Congress.
The miracle of our great United States Constitution is that it has lasted for two centuries, accommodating our great geographic and economic expansion, while preserving individual liberties. If it ain't broke, don't try to fix it.