Michael G. New enlisted in the U.S. Army in 1993, and for two years served with distinction as a medic. In 1995, he won the Army Achievement Medal for treating a badly injured soldier in an emergency situation.
In August 1995, while assigned to the 1st Battalion, 15th Infantry Regiment, 3d Infantry Division in Schweinfurt, Germany, Specialist New received an order that would change his life.
The order required every soldier in his battalion to wear a shoulder patch, badge, blue scarf, blue field cap and beret, all bearing the emblem of the United Nations (UN). His battalion commander acknowledged that these accouterments constituted the UN uniform. In addition, these American soldiers were ordered to carry a UN identification card.
Specialist New recalled his oath to defend the US Constitution. He told his superiors, "I am an American who was recruited for and voluntarily joined the U.S. Army to serve as an American soldier. . . . I am not a United Nations Fighting Person."
Specialist New could not in good conscience swap his American uniform for a UN uniform, which he viewed as unlawful. He offered to be transferred to anywhere else in the world, no matter how dangerous, consistent with his constitutional oath.
Instead, the Army insisted on a court martial for Specialist New. In prosecuting New, the Army did not call any witnesses to establish the legality of the order. United States v. Michael G. New.
A retired Marine Lieutenant and former U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee staff member, David Sullivan, testified for New that prior Congressional approval was required to justify the UN deployment. Neither the Department of Defense nor the Department of the Army authorized, informally or formally, the United Nations deployment and use of its uniform.
Yet the military judge prohibited Specialist New from presenting his challenge to the lawfulness of the order to the military jury. Instead, the military judge instructed the jury that the order was lawful and Specialist New had a duty to obey it. The judge allowed the jury to acquit New only if he did not know of the order or was mistaken as to its contents.
After the military jury convicted New and sentenced him to a bad conduct discharge, the case was appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces. After deliberating for well over a year, that court held 3-2 against New as to whether he was entitled to challenge the order before the military jury, and 5-0 against New on his request to overturn the conviction.
The military Court of Appeals, like the military trial court, never did address the legality of ordering American soldiers to wear foreign uniforms. Instead, the Court characterized the order at issue as "nonjusticiable," beyond challenge in the judiciary.
Specialist New appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. But consistent with its reluctance to adjudicate military issues, the Court declined on October 9th to consider the appeal.
The implications of this case extend far beyond Michael New's personal career. Can a future President now order U.S. troops to serve in a UN uniform? How does this decision relate to President Clinton's 1994 Presidential Decision Directive 25, which purports to authorize the President "to place U.S. forces under the operational control of a foreign commander" and under foreign rules of engagement?