Court Monitor • Dec 2, 2001

Can Someone Own the Law?

Text Reader

Privately owned coding systems have been creeping into legal requirements, from building safety codes to Medicare billing procedures. Some laws require the public to use privately owned standards or face civil and criminal liability. For example, all Medicare bills must use codes licensed by the American Medical Association (AMA). Called the Current Procedural Terminology (CPT), these codes include thousands of simple 5-digit numbers used to identify each medical procedure paid by Medicare. Physicians must repeatedly buy manuals, seminars, journals, and other explanatory materials, all of which generate royalties for the AMA. Senator Trent Lott estimated that the AMA receives about $71 million annually for its government-conferred monopoly. A courageous Texan named Peter Veeck decided that no one should own the law. He posted some building safety codes on the internet that all local contractors are required by law to comply with, but which a private association claims to own. Southern Building Code Congress International Inc. (SBCCI), the publisher of the codes that Veeck posted, argued in court that Veeck was interfering with its property and business by providing the codes free to the public. The district court held in favor of SBCCI, basing its decision on the potential for lost business by SBCCI if Veeck were allowed to post the codes on the internet. Veeck appealed. He argued that no one can own the law. He asserted that the public should have free, electronic access to the laws that all of us must obey, under threat of prosecution. Many other private organizations, which also sell government-required codes, appeared on the side of SBCCI during the appeal. They defended their government-conferred monopolies over legal requirements. They claimed to save the government money by developing codes and standards with their own funds, rather than at taxpayer expense. Moreover, they argued that they should not lose their ownership simply because a municipality incorporates their codes into the law. The flaw in those arguments is that organizations such as SBCCI and the AMA actively seek to have government impose their codes by law, and it is the law that makes their codes valuable. It is doubtful that their codes would have much value in the absence of the legal requirements. Over 100 years ago, a company hired to publish state judicial opinions claimed a copyright in them. The Supreme Court rejected the copyright because the published material was "the authentic exposition and interpretation of the law, which, binding every citizen, is free for publication to all." Banks v. Manchester, 128 U.S. 244, 253 (1888). The same principle should prevent claims of ownership in the law today. Unfortunately, a panel of the Fifth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals held, by a 2-1 margin, in favor of SBCCI. The dissenting opinion agreed with Veeck and was compelling in its argument. Laws are essentially facts which a copyright cannot protect. Once SBCCI's codes were imposed by law, no copyright should be allowed to prevent their posting by Veeck or anyone else. The entire Fifth Circuit recently ordered a re-consideration of the case by all 14 active judges. A new decision is expected by next summer.