A Pennsylvania public school district went to court to try to revoke the tax exemption of a private school based on its single-sex admissions policy. On appeal, a Pennsylvania court recently held unanimously in favor of the private school.
In Pottstown School District v. Hill School, No. 1501 C.D. 2000 (Nov. 1, 2001, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania turned back this latest attempt by a public school district to close down a competitor. In so doing, the court also brushed off application of the state Equal Rights Amendment.
The Hill School, a private college preparatory school in the Pottstown School District in Montgomery County, limited its enrollment to boys prior to 1998. So the public school district tried to use Pennsylvania's state Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) to drive it out of business.
The public school district insisted that taxes be assessed on land owned by the Hill School, and filed a petition to that effect in May 1996 before the Board of Assessment Appeals. The local borough joined the petition, and the matter ultimately landed in a county court. The public school petitioners argued that the Hill School discriminated based on sex, and therefore could not qualify as a public charity entitled to tax exemption. The county court initially agreed and assessed back property taxes on the Hill School.
The Hill School asked the court to reverse its own verdict, which courts rarely do. This time, however, the court did reinstate the tax exemption. The public school district didn't give up; it responded by appealing.
The public school district apparently hoped that the Pennsylvania courts would strip its competitor of tax exemption, just as the Supreme Court (over the dissent of now-Chief Justice Rehnquist) once denied a tax exemption to Bob Jones University. Bob Jones Univ. v. United States, 461 U.S. 574 (1983)
Not so fast. Pennsylvania's appellate court held that, while the legislature has the power to deny tax exemption to non-religious single-sex schools, it has not done so.
In siding with the Hill School, the appellate court ruled that the tax exemption is available "as long as the admission/enrollment criteria [do] not violate federal or state anti-discrimination laws." The Hill School was, in fact, in compliance with applicable anti-discrimination laws, which exempt single-sex schools that do not accept government subsidies.
Two judges, in reluctant concurrence, grasped for the Pennsylvania Equal Rights Amendment. They claimed sweeping authority for the feminist view that ERA "circumscribes the conduct of state and local government entities and officials of all levels in the formulation, interpretation and enforcement of statutes, regulations, ordinances and other legislation as well as decisional law."
These two judges stated that they might have revoked Hill School's tax exemption, based on the state ERA, if the only single-sex schools in the state were all-male. Gratuitously, they also cast aspersions on the view that many students benefit from single-sex education.
The U.S. Supreme Court has held that, in the absence of a federal ERA, "We do not question [a state's] prerogative evenhandedly to support diverse educational opportunities." United States v. Virginia, 518 U.S. 515, 534 n.7 (1996)