Court Monitor • May 14, 2001

Wyoming Affirms Parental Rights

Text Reader

Two important court decisions were rendered during March by the Wyoming Supreme Court in the context of unwanted vaccination. The Wyoming State Department of Health had refused to allow Mrs. LePage's daughter to attend school unless and until she received the controversial hepatitis B vaccine. The agency took this position even though teachers are not required to receive that vaccine and there is no meaningful threat of hepatitis B contagion in the school environment. Mrs. LePage invoked the religious exemption to vaccination that is available in Wyoming and nearly all states. She expressed her view that hepatitis B is contracted through an immoral lifestyle and rejected that vaccine for her daughter. The Wyoming agency decided that Mrs. LePage's objection was not religious enough, and refused to accept it. It asserted that Mrs. LePage's objection was based on personal, moral or philosophical belief, but not religious belief. It refused to allow her daughter to attend school until she received the hepatitis B vaccine. The Wyoming Supreme Court reversed in LePage v. Wyoming. It held that "we ... are confident in our presumption that parents act in the best interest of their children's physical, as well as their spiritual, health." Parents, not government, must retain authority over medical treatment for their children. The decision also affirmed a rule that other courts would do well to follow. "Any agency decision that falls outside the confines of the statutory guidelines articulated by the legislature is contrary to law and cannot stand," the court declared. In the companion case of Jones v. Wyoming, the court considered a similar issue. There the student's own physician recommended against his receiving the hepatitis B vaccine and the parent claimed the medical exemption, but the Wyoming agency insisted on excluding him from school anyway until he received it. Again, the Wyoming Supreme Court reversed the decision of its Department of Health. "We do not believe the legislature necessarily intended to authorize the Department of Health to interrogate students regarding specifics of their medical condition." Put another way, parents are to make medical decisions about their children with the advice of their physician. Government does not have the authority to require medical treatment over the objection of parents and their physician. It is rare and courageous for a court to hold so squarely against the government in this manner. In the LePage decision, the court even issued a warning to the legislature to avoid infringing on parental rights in the future. "It is the legislature's responsibility to act within the constraints of the Wyoming and United States Constitutions." The Wyoming Supreme Court showed great leadership in these decisions, which other courts should follow. Parents can make better decisions about their children than government can. Schools should not impose intrusive requirements on students with which the teachers themselves need not comply. For example, teachers are not required to answer the nosy questionnaires that are often given to students. Neither should the students have to answer them.