Court Monitor • May 28, 2001

Internet Versus the Media Middlemen

Text Reader

The Internet has great promise for reducing bias in the media, and we have already seen significant changes. The evening television news, which once had a stranglehold on spinning the daily news, is now relegated to second place because the Internet reports uncensored news instantaneously. The Napster decisions in federal court in California have highlighted this struggle between middlemen and the Internet, which allows the delivery of information straight to the public. The Napster legal battle has seesawed back and forth. Round I went to the middlemen (the recording industry and retailers), Round II went to Napster, Round III went slightly to the middlemen, and Round IV has gone slightly to Napster. In Round I the recording industry demanded in district court that the Napster website be completely shut down merely because some (but not all) of its usage violated copyrights. It was a typical liberal argument: prohibit activity that is legal in order to stop illegal activity. On July 26th the district court sided with the recording industry, and gave Napster only 48 hours to terminate its website and its business. On July 28, just before the expiration of the 48 hours, two appellate judges issued a stay that saved Napster from extinction. Much usage on Napster, after all, is perfectly legitimate. Moreover, the trial court had not even held a full evidentiary hearing to determine if the recording industry's broad claims were accurate. Napster survived - until the next round. While waiting for a decision by a full panel of the Court of Appeals, a German company Bertelsmann then struck a deal with Napster to cooperate on music delivery over the Internet. But the U.S.-based recording companies wouldn't budge from their demand to retain control. Later, Napster and the German company even offered a $1 billion settlement to the middlemen, but were turned down. Round III - the decision by a full panel of the federal Court of Appeals in February - went slightly to the recording industry. It requires Napster to stop downloading songs identified by the recording industry as proprietary. But, and this is key, Napster would not be shut down and the recording industry bore the burden of identifying specific illegitimate copying. But the media, which is sympathetic to the recording industry (perhaps due to a similarity in interests), exaggerated this ruling as being the demise of Napster. Round IV is back before the district court. In March, the judge allowed Napster to continue to operate, and it need only prevent specifically identified violations of copyright law. It continues to thrive with many millions of users, with only about a 10% decline in traffic since its predicted demise. To paraphrase Mark Twain, reports of Napster's death have been greatly exaggerated. The free market will sort out the economics of the Napster case. But the good news is that the days of a few middlemen selecting the songs for a nation are going extinct - as also should the liberal middlemen who spin news and politics.