Court Monitor • Jun 21, 2001

Withholding Information in the McVeigh Case

Text Reader

In the aftermath of the tragic bombing in Oklahoma City on April 19, 1995, which killed 168 persons, newspapers nationwide featured drawings of suspects John Doe No. 1 and John Doe No. 2. A witness saw two men rent the Ryder truck used in the attack, and other witnesses saw a pair before and after the massive killing. Witnesses reported seeing a man get out of the passenger side of the truck. The government has refused to release the FBI's surveillance tapes of the area just before the bombing. One of those suspects, Timothy McVeigh, fit the John Doe No. 1 sketch perfectly, was soon captured, and then tried before Judge Richard Matsch in Denver. The jury found McVeigh guilty and sentenced him to death. Later, a co-conspirator in the bombing, Terry Nichols, was also found guilty, although he was not alleged to have been suspect John Doe No. 2. Nichols looks nothing like the sketch of that suspect, and Nichols' jury did not sentence him to death. The government's case against McVeigh was simple and forceful: he was allegedly both the mastermind and bomber in the attack. The government later told us that John Doe No. 2 never really existed and abruptly ended investigations about that suspect. It is common in brutal murder cases for the mastermind of the killings to receive the death penalty while his accomplices receive multiple life sentences. The jury, accepting the government theory, sentenced McVeigh to death as the person most responsible for the tragedy. A few weeks before McVeigh's scheduled execution, the FBI admitted that it had failed to provide more than 4,400 pages of documents to McVeigh's defense team, which could have been shown to his jury. Whether the withholding was negligent or intentional, the effect was the same: the jury and the public did not hear the entire story about who perpetrated this heinous crime. On June 6th, the trial Judge Matsch said he was "shocked" that the FBI had withheld the documents and said "he would expect there will be consequences." Without providing a written explanation, he refused to delay the execution. The Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit quickly affirmed, and the execution proceeded on schedule on June 11, 2001. United States v. McVeigh, No. 96-CR-68-M. But will there be consequences? If this were any other death penalty case, it is unlikely that the judge would have allowed the execution to go forward. Judge Matsch admitted that new evidence could suggest involvement by others, but said "it will not change the fact that Timothy McVeigh was the instrument of death and destruction." Will this ruling prevent public disclosure and testimony about the more than 4,400 FBI documents withheld in the case, and the recent court filings made under seal? Doesn't the public have a right to know who else might have been responsible for this horrible murder? It is regrettable that courts increasingly operate outside of the public view with sealed filings, unpublished opinions and, in this case, documents and surveillance tapes withheld from the trial. Now that McVeigh has met his fate, all documents and filings should be unsealed immediately. The American people have a right to know all the facts about the most publicized crime of our time, and secrecy will lead to endless speculation.