When federal officers violate the Constitution, either through malice or excessive zeal, they can be held accountable for violating the state's criminal laws." So wrote Judge Alex Kozinski in a 6-5 decision of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Idaho v. Horiuchi, No. 98-1049, June 5, 2001.
http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/data2/circs/9th/9830149p.pdf
This was the latest episode in the tragedy known as Ruby Ridge. A close decision and a hard-fought case, it finally vindicated the proposition that federal law enforcement officers are subject to the law.
Before dawn on August 21, 1992, six heavily-armed deputy U.S. marshals with night vision gear and camouflage clothing descended on Randy Weaver's family cabin, high in an Idaho forest. The marshals were supposedly scouting out the property for a later return, but were still there at 10:20 a.m. when they encountered Weaver, his 14-year-old son Sam, a family friend named Kevin Harris, and the family dog.
According to reports, a marshal shot and killed the family dog and a shoot-out ensued. One U.S. marshal was killed, and the marshals killed the 14-year-old with a fatal shot to his back.
The next day, the FBI placed 11 snipers in concealed positions around the cabin, along with a helicopter to fly overhead. Unaware of the snipers, Weaver, his 16-year-old daughter, and Harris came out of the cabin to check on Sam's body.
One of those snipers was Lon Horiuchi, a West Point graduate and former infantry officer, well-trained for war. But police work is very different from soldier work. Horiuchi fired at Weaver as he approached his son's body, striking Weaver in the arm.
Horiuchi acted as he was trained to act, more like a soldier in a war zone than a policeman on residential property. He used military terminology in explaining what precipitated his shooting. To Horiuchi, Weaver and his family might as well have been the Viet Cong, even though they were peacefully walking on their own property.
Twenty seconds later, as Harris fled back into the cabin, Horiuchi shot into the cabin. The sharpshooter's bullet hit Mrs. Weaver in the head as she was holding her 10-month-old child, killing her instantly.
The FBI refused to take remedial action. An Idaho prosecutor brought manslaughter charges against Horiuchi and retained a special prosecutor to lead the effort. The FBI pulled out all the stops to prevent a trial, and federal courts initially agreed.
At the appellate level, however, Federal Judge Alex Kozinski saw something wrong with an FBI agent killing a mother standing peacefully in her own home. He led the way to a rehearing by the full Ninth Circuit court and then wrote the decision cited above allowing Idaho's prosecution to proceed.
A new Idaho prosecutor again acquiesced in government demands that the manslaughter charges be dismissed. The special prosecutor originally appointed to this case criticized the decision not to prosecute: "It sounds to me like the system has suffered a temporary corruption." The case may not be over because there is no statute of limitations on murder and a subsequent prosecutor could bring charges against Horiuchi.
Both Harris and Weaver were tried and acquitted of wrongdoing. In 1995, the government paid Weaver $3.1 million for killing his wife Vicki and his son Sam. In 2000, the government paid Harris $380,000 for his injuries inflicted by the FBI sniper.