Court Monitor • Jun 4, 2001

Offensive School Testing Upheld in New Jersey

Text Reader

As every politician and attorney knows, one can shape opinions by asking slanted questions. "When did you stop beating your wife?" is the classic example of a question that offensively frames the respondent. Imagine more than a hundred offensive questions given in the coercive atmosphere of a classroom to students aged 12 through 17. Such a case was presented to a federal district court in New Jersey in C.N. v. Ridgewood, Civ. No. 00-1072 (NHP) (Feb. 15, 2001). The court handed down an anti-parent decision under the headline "Not for Publication." It gives New Jersey schools carte blanche to ask offensive questions of students without prior parental consent. The purpose of the questionnaire was not academic. It was designed by local social service agencies to poll the town's youth, and was later foisted on students by the public school superintendent. The questionnaire consisted of 156 personal questions, many of which would incriminate the students. The allowed answer selections were on a relative scale, from "Strongly Agree" to "Strongly Disagree." Had these questions been asked of youths in any other venue, most would likely have stopped answering long before completion. But in the coercive atmosphere of the classroom, students are expected to complete their assignments. The court cited nothing to suggest that the students or their parents knew in advance what was buried among the 156 intrusive questions. Questions such as "It is against my values to have sex while I am a teenager" were included, and an absolute "yes" was not a permissible answer. When some parents discovered this outrage, they sued to stop its repetition. The court, however, dismissed the parents' complaint and even described the offensive questionnaire as a "good deed." The court rejected the parents' argument against self-incrimination based on the school's promises of confidentiality, although most attorneys would advise clients against self-incrimination no matter how strong the assurance of confidentiality. The court also denied parents and students a meaningful First Amendment right not to speak. In cases involving union objections to government or employer surveys, courts have typically sided with the worker being questioned. Not so for students and parents, who are consistently denied rights available to unions. The court held that representations by the superintendent to parents that a voluntary and anonymous survey would be conducted, and instructions that students should be told the same, constituted all the notice that was required. In fact, there was no indication in the court's opinion that there had been meaningful notice of the content of the questions, or that students had any realistic opportunity to walk out of the test after discovering its offensive content. The court refused to require prior parental consent for this offensive questioning of students.