Court Monitor • Jul 18, 2001

Yes, Microsoft Did Violate the Antitrust Law

Text Reader

It was the business trial of the century: the world's richest man, Bill Gates, accused of violating the antitrust law. His answers under oath were unpersuasive to the judge and provoked laughter in the courtroom, and the judge held that Microsoft should be broken up due to its wrongdoing. In a recent 7-0 ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals affirmed that, yes, Microsoft really had violated the antitrust law. United States v. Microsoft Corp., No. 00-5212 (D.C. Cir. June 28, 2001) Microsoft's crime was not that it was successful or rich or even that it was a monopoly, but that it unreasonably interfered with competition and free enterprise. Antitrust law, codified in the Sherman Act passed by Republicans in the late 1800s, is a major pillar of the free enterprise system. It preserves free competition against monopolies that use their monopoly power to disrupt competition. The Court of Appeals first held that Microsoft is a monopoly, and then held that it violated the Sherman Act's prohibition against a monopoly engaging in anti-competitive practices. Specifically, the Court held that Microsoft unlawfully restricted computer manufacturers in selling products by Microsoft's competitors. The Court of Appeals agreed with the trial judge that Microsoft maintains its monopoly over operating systems by imposing licensing restrictions on computer makers that interfere with the use of competitors' software. These licensing restrictions were part of contracts that were secret, thereby enabling Microsoft to adjust its price depending on the cooperation of the computer maker. Microsoft thus used its monopoly power and exclusionary licensing to exclude the products of competitors, such as Netscape, from full access to the market. As noted in a recent Wall Street Journal Op-Ed by former Judges Robert Bork and Ken Starr, Microsoft "was found to have destroyed the nascent threats to its operating system monopoly.... Singly or in combination, these could ... threaten Microsoft's monopoly by making users and application writers indifferent to the operating system used...This was a violation of the Sherman Act." Microsoft's exclusionary licensing practices required computer makers to rig all their computers so that Microsoft's software would be used instead of competitors' software. This is how Microsoft stifled innovation, a strategy which, according to recent news reports, it continues to pursue with its forthcoming Windows XP product. In rejecting Microsoft's claim that its copyright on Windows immunizes exercise of that copyright from antitrust liability, the Court observed that Microsoft's argument "borders upon the frivolous." The Court thus upheld the central holding of the trial judge: that Microsoft has a monopoly, and that it violated antitrust law in the way it acted to maintain that monopoly. Case closed? Unfortunately, no. The Court remanded the entire case to a new judge unfamiliar with the proceedings in order to consider a new remedy other than break-up. That may delay final resolution by several more years while Microsoft can continue violating antitrust law. The Court of Appeals apparently took offense at Judge Jackson's criticism in the press concerning its earlier handling of the case, and removed him from it. In that 1995 case, the Court of Appeals had implied that bundling of an internet browser with the operating system was probably legal, but after the trial, the Court had to agree in large part with Judge Jackson's decision.