Court Monitor • Jul 29, 2001

Supreme Court Closes Medical Necessity Loophole

Text Reader

The Supreme Court recently closed the "medical necessity" loophole to generally applicable laws. It denied a medical necessity exception to the prohibition on distributing illicit drugs. U.S. v. Oakland Cannabis Buyers Cooperative, No. 00-151 (May 14, 2001). Medical necessity has long been a liberal argument for circumventing restrictions on abortion, assisted suicide, drugs, and now stem cell research. In Doe v. Bolton, 410 U.S. 179 (1973) (issued simultaneously with Roe v. Wade and setting the legal standard ever since), the Court invented a broad alleged medical justification for abortion that even extends to alleged emotional needs. Federal law expressly prohibits the sale of certain harmful drugs, including marijuana, but the drug legalization movement seized upon alleged medical need to bypass the law. The Supreme Court stopped the end run for drug suppliers. "Under any conception of legal necessity, one principle is clear: The defense cannot succeed when the legislature itself has made a determination of values," held Justice Clarence Thomas, speaking for the Court. He thereby closed the loophole that liberals have repeatedly used to subvert general laws. Justice Thomas continued: "The Controlled Substances Act provides that, except as authorized by this subchapter, it shall be unlawful for any person knowingly or intentionally to manufacture, distribute, or dispense, or possess with intent to manufacture, distribute, or dispense, a controlled substance. 21 U.S.C. 841(a)(1)." The "value" that this act determined is that we do not want marijuana distributed to our children and our neighbors. An Oakland, California marijuana supplier tried to assert its own values and provide this drug to persons who asserted any medical need. To obtain marijuana, the customers merely presented a written statement from a physician assenting to their use of marijuana and submitted to a screening interview. The drug supplier claimed that the federal statute outlawing drug distribution includes an implied exception for alleged medical need. California is one of about 9 states in which alleged medical need for marijuana has persuaded voters to carve a medical-use exception to state restrictions, typically through referenda. In this case, the district judge applied the federal statute to stop the distribution of marijuana, but the Ninth Circuit reversed and invented a medical exception to the law. The Supreme Court overturned that decision, as it has so frequently done to the Ninth Circuit. The Supreme Court decision was unanimous, with Justice Breyer taking no part in the decision because his brother was the district court judge. Its ruling is pivotal to keeping harmful drugs illegal, and also has great significance for other social issues. It is possible that the alleged broad medical need for abortion declared in Doe v. Bolton may no longer be good law. Justice Stevens and two other liberal judges criticized the majority opinion for eliminating the medical necessity defense. They complained that "the Court gratuitously casts doubt on whether necessity can ever be a defense to any federal statute that does not explicitly provide for it." However, Congress, not the courts, is the branch of government empowered to establish medical necessity exceptions to general laws. We thank the Supreme Court for resisting the temptation to indulge in judicial activism.