Court Monitor • Aug 22, 2001

'Mena Connection' Vindication

Text Reader

Two teenage boys were run over by a train on Arkansas railroad tracks in 1987, during Bill Clinton's tenure as Governor. A local autopsy said the deaths were accidental, but a second autopsy concluded that they were homicides, with the bodies presumably placed on the railroad tracks to conceal the crime. After a lawsuit, the death certificates were changed to homicide. An ordained Baptist minister, Pat Matrisciana, produced a documentary in 1996 about this incident entitled "Obstruction of Justice: the Mena Connection." Two officers of the Pulaski County Sheriff's Office (which includes the state capital of Little Rock) sued and obtained a libel judgment against Matrisciana for about $600,000. In a well-deserved reversal, the Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit vacated the award and dismissed the lawsuit. Campbell and Lane v. Citizens for an Honest Government Inc., No. 00-1411 (8th Cir. July 10, 2001). The Court did not address the alleged drug smuggling at Intermountain Regional Airport at Mena or speculation that the teenagers were murdered because of what they saw at the airport. The unanimous Court did determine that the officers had failed to show that key assertions in the video were false. The officers "did not satisfy their burden of proving falsity by at least a preponderance of the evidence." The Court noted, for example, that neither officer in the case provided an alibi for his whereabouts when the teenagers were murdered. The Court even found a flaw in the excuse provided by one officer for why he did not have an alibi. The Court recounted the statements of several eyewitnesses who saw the teenagers the night of their deaths. Those statements supported claims in the documentary about official involvement related to the murders. For example, the Court relied on statements by a Ronnie Godwin. Godwin gave two separate, consistent statements in which he described two police officers in a confrontation with two teenagers outside a grocery store where other eyewitnesses reported seeing the boys on the night of the murders. Godwin stated that he saw the officers drive off with the boys in their car, and then return five or ten minutes later with what looked like a garbage bag in the back seat instead. Although Godwin was subpoenaed for the libel trial, the plaintiff officers released him without having him testify about his statements. Arkansas ultimately appointed a special prosecutor to investigate the murders and convened a grand jury to hear testimony. An inference that the officers were suspects arose from the prosecutor's statement that the real murderers would be testifying on a day that the officers did testify. The Court also held that the defendants lacked malice in producing the video; this provided an independent basis for dismissing the case. The necessity of proving malice in libel cases involving public figures has been widely known ever since the famous Paul Newman movie Absence of Malice. In vindicating Pat Matrisciana, the Court dealt another setback to the Clinton apologists who brush off and cannot explain the dozens of unexplained deaths surrounding his tenure as Governor and President.