Whatever happened to the maxim that a "man's home is his castle"? Government prohibiting the use of your own land has become a growing problem.
In Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council, Inc. v. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency, Nos. 99-15641, 99-15771 (June 15, 2000), the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals declared that government can deny use of private land without compensation, as long as the denial is temporary.
Owners had purchased lots near Lake Tahoe with the hope of building vacation or retirement homes. However, a Tahoe Regional Planning Agency was created under legislation passed in Nevada, California and Congress to protect Lake Tahoe and its surrounding basin.
The agency imposed a moratorium on building for nearly three years, but this prohibition has lasted for nearly twenty years. Owners have been deprived of reasonable use of their property for nearly a generation. The Ninth Circuit held that government need not compensate them.
The Fifth Amendment includes what is called the Takings Clause: "nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation." Government may take private property for public purposes such as building highways or protecting the environment, but must fairly compensate the owners.
The Supreme Court has emphasized that "while property may be regulated to a certain extent, if regulation goes too far it will be recognized as a taking." Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahon, 260 U.S. 393 (1922). Regulations that deprive an owner of all use and enjoyment of his property should trigger Fifth Amendment compensation. Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council, 505 U.S. 1003, 1016 (1992).
But Judge Reinhardt of the Ninth Circuit (who has been frequently reversed by the Supreme Court) held that regulations prohibiting property use for temporary time periods do not require Fifth Amendment compensation. Adopting a 1967 argument by a Harvard Law School professor, Judge Reinhardt and the Ninth Circuit held that possibility of future use enables government to deprive the owner of all present use without compensation. Under this approach, government could deprive an owner of all use and enjoyment for a fixed time period as long as potential future use protects much of its market value.
After losing, the owners moved for reconsideration of their case. Although reconsideration was denied, Judge Kozinski wrote a stinging dissent.
"The requirement of just compensation ensures that the few are not forced to bear the cost of uses that benefit the many," noted Judge Kozinski. Lake Tahoe is beautiful, and regulation to preserve that beauty may be justified, but the many should compensate the few harmed by the preservation effort.
Continuing, Judge Kozinski wrote: "The panel does not like the Supreme Court's Takings Clause jurisprudence very much, so it reverses First English Evangelical Lutheran Church v. County of Los Angeles, 482 U.S. 304 (1987)." He added, "we have neglected our duty and passed the burden of correcting our mistake on to a higher authority."
That observation was prophetic, as the Supreme Court has granted plaintiffs' petition to review the case. With government regulation of private property rapidly increasing, this may be one of the Supreme Court's most important current cases.