It looked tailor-made for gun control: a lawsuit against a gun manufacturer in the liberal California court system concerning a shooting massacre. This would be, many thought, the precedent to bankrupt an industry, as the breast implant litigation has done.
But in a 5-1 decision, the California Supreme Court just said no. It reversed the decision of the lower Court of Appeals, which had subjected the gun manufacturer to liability for a massacre.
The case involved a shooting spree by Gian Luigi Ferri on July 1, 1993, when he entered a high-rise San Francisco office building with semiautomatic assault pistols manufactured by defendant Navegar. Acting on a grudge against a law firm, he killed eight and wounded six, and then committed suicide.
Several sued to hold Navegar liable for the maniacal actions of Mr. Ferri. But there was no evidence that Navegar's advertising or other statements had incited this heinous crime.
Plaintiffs nevertheless argued that Navegar should be liable because it sold such a weapon to the general public. Plaintiffs insisted that Navegar had a "legal duty" not to distribute it widely.
That argument, if successful, could stop many guns sales. Who could predict whether an emotional jury would approve of a given gun?
Nor could this approach be confined to guns. Fast cars, hunting knives, hard liquor, and certain prescription drugs can also be associated with tragic deaths. Would industry liability be next for them?
The Court discussed how the lawsuit essentially asked the Court to balance the risks of Navegar's gun against its possible benefits to society. Such arbitrary risk/benefit balancing by a jury would be unavoidable if a trial were allowed to proceed.
The Court noted that the legislature had passed a statute mandating that "a gun manufacturer may not be held liable 'in a products liability action . . . on the basis that the benefits of [its] product do not outweigh the risk of injury posed by [the product's] potential to cause serious injury, damage, or death when discharged.' Civ. Code, §1714.4, subd. (a)."
On the basis of this statutory protection, the Court held in favor of the gun manufacturer. "In section 1714.4, the Legislature has set California's public policy regarding a gun manufacturer's liability under these circumstances [and] plaintiffs may not proceed with their negligence claim."
The dissent, miffed at the judicial restraint, insisted that the gun manufacturer should stand trial for the massacre, and concluded with a liberal call for the legislature to repeal the above statute.
Despite the setbacks, the liberal chant for gun control continues. That's because the liberal takeover of politics in England can be largely attributed to one massacre followed by the passage of strict gun control.
In response to a school shooting in Scotland in 1996, Britain banned private ownership of all handguns above .22 caliber. The impact? Defenseless English voters have since handed liberals their biggest election victories in a century, the effect sought by liberals in America, while crimes entailing guns used for violence against the person have increased substantially.