Court Monitor • Sep 9, 2001

Court Pokes More Holes in Our Porous Border

Text Reader

It was a day in the life of a patrol agent near our porous Arizona-Mexico border. He did his job, but then the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals undid it. United States v. Arvizu, Civ. No. CR-98-00157 (9th Cir. July 7, 2000, amended Dec. 1, 2000). One afternoon, Border Patrol Agent Stoddard noticed a suspicious minivan driving north on an unpaved road in Coronado National Forest. Since this was near the Mexico border, the agent was suspicious of smuggling. He noticed the car was traveling near the time of a border guard change, which smugglers are known to exploit. Moreover, the van was using an unpaved bypass to the border station. Marijuana had been found in another minivan traveling that same route only a month earlier. Doing his job, Agent Stoddard drove to the car and noticed additional suspicious factors. The driver, Ralph Arvizu, appeared nervous and rigid, and did not acknowledge the officer as most drivers do in that area. The children inside the van then waved repeatedly to the agent for four or five minutes, as though they had been instructed to do so by the adults in the front seat. Agent Stoddard, familiar with the local cars, could not recognize this van. He ran a license plate check and found it registered to an address in an area associated with drug smuggling. He stopped the car to investigate further. Agent Stoddard testified that the driver was unable to identify the park to which he was supposedly driving and that the driver gave him consent for searching the car. But the driver later claimed to have misinterpreted the agent's request to be that he would look only outside of the car rather than inside it. Agent Stoddard found a black duffel bag of marijuana in the van. Driver Arvizu subsequently agreed to a guilty plea if this evidence were allowed against him. But the Ninth Circuit, in an opinion written by the often-reversed Judge Stephen Reinhardt, suppressed the evidence as illegally obtained. This decision cripples border patrols in two ways. It requires that border agents obtain greater incriminating evidence prior to stopping particular cars, and it also blocks use of some evidence found during a stop. Agent Stoddard's grounds for suspicion probably exceeded that presented in most smuggling cases. Yet the Court dismissed his factors by viewing each in isolation, a tactic commonly used by the defense. For example, Judge Reinhardt said the lack of eye contact between the driver and Agent Stoddard "provides no support" for suspicion. Ditto for the registration of the car in a high crime area, according to the Ninth Circuit. How about the van's use of an unpaved bypass to the border patrol, a road where another drug smuggler had been caught just a month earlier? The Court dismissed this by saying the van could have been going to camping areas, even though the driver could not identify the park of his alleged destination. This decision illustrates one reason why our borders are porous. Fortunately, the Supreme Court has taken this case and has a chance to reverse it this fall.