One of the controversies that emerged during the ratification of the U. S. Constitution focused on the independence of the federal judiciary. The anti-federalists, led by Patrick Henry and George Mason, believed it would be too independent, and hence unaccountable to the citizenry. Alexander Hamilton, in the Federalist Papers, opposed electing federal judges because he feared they would rely on popularity rather than the Rule of Law. More than two centuries later, a similar debate has reached our High Court.
In Minnesota, the public elects its state Supreme Court judges, who are sharply limited in their campaigning by Canon 5 of the Minnesota Code of Judicial Conduct.
Republican Gregory Wersal campaigned for election to the Minnesota Supreme Court on a platform of Astrict construction of the Constitution. He spoke at Republican party gatherings and distributed campaign literature criticizing several Minnesota decisions on issues of crime, welfare and abortion.
But Canon 5 restricts judicial candidates from attending and speaking at partisan political gatherings, declaring one's party membership, or seeking party endorsements. It prohibits solicitation of campaign contributions and even statements of the candidate's views on disputed legal and political issues.
Wersal and the Republican Party sued to overturn Canon 5. No one doubts that Canon 5 sharply restricts the political speech of judicial candidates, speech that lies at the heart of the protections of the First Amendment. The only issue is whether there is a compelling reason to restrict such speech.
The Eighth Circuit cited many instances where restrictions on political speech have been upheld. For example, in 1973 the U.S. Supreme Court sensibly upheld a prohibition on federal employees taking an active part in political campaigns. CSC v. Letter Carriers, 413 U.S. 548 (1973). More recently, the Court upheld limitations on how much money one can contribute to a candidate. Nixon v. Shrink Missouri Gov't PAC, 528 U.S. 377 (2000).
In a 2-1 decision, the federal Eighth Circuit upheld the constitutionality of Canon 5. Republican Party of Minnesota v. Kelly, 247 F.3d 854 (8th Cir.), cert. granted, 122 S. Ct. 643 (2001). The Eighth Circuit observed the need to avoid the perception that justice is for sale, and expressed concern about judges presiding over issues for which they have already made campaign promises. U.S. Supreme Court nominees usually avoid these problems by refusing to answer questions about controversial issues.
But this difficult matter of judicial independence has two sides, as the Eighth Circuit dissenting opinion makes clear. Like Shakespeare's Mark Antony, it accepted the premises of the honorable majority but turned their arguments against Canon 5. It noted that Minnesota need not use public elections to select judges, but if it does, then the elections must Acome replete with speech and associational rights.
Minnesota and many other states seek some electoral legitimacy and accountability for their judiciary, something in between the approaches of the colonial federalists and anti-federalists. The U.S. Supreme Court will soon try to resolve this debate.