Court Monitor • Oct 13, 2002

The First Amendment Protects Criticism of Feminism in the Military

Text Reader

It looked like protected First Amendment speech from the outset. The Center for Military Readiness (CMR), led by Elaine Donnelly, published reports critical of the Clinton Administration’s deployment of the first female fighter pilots. President Clinton wanted to place women in combat positions as a sop to feminist groups. In January 1994 his Secretary of Defense, Les Aspin, authorized the assignment of women in most combat ships, many previously closed positions on land, and fighter aircraft. The first of two women trained to fly the F-14 Tomcat was Lt. Kara Hultgreen, beginning in the summer of 1994. That fighter aircraft was featured in the popular movie Top Gun. But her career was tragically short-lived. On October 25, 1994, she died during a landing maneuver on approach to the USS Abraham Lincoln. Her plane and life were lost, though her radar intercept officer was able to eject to safety. Her death spawned scrutiny by the media of the military’s new use of females as fighter pilots. W. Kent Davis, a naval officer on board the ship, later published a law journal article describing the incident and subsequent cover-up. "Opponents of women in combat suspected that [Lt. Hultgreen] had been rushed into her new role and promoted above her level of skill simply because she was a woman. Navy investigators at first discounted this possibility, blaming the crash on engine failure. However, a secret copy of the actual Mishap Investigation Report, in which the crash was blamed on pilot error, was eventually leaked to the public" (by someone still unknown). Davis, "Swords into Plowshares the Dangerous Politicalization of the Military in the Post-Cold War Era," 33 Val. U.L. Rev. 61, 98 (1998). Bucking the feminist agenda is not for the faint of heart. Starting in 1995, CMR questioned the practice of adjusting standards so that female pilots could be rushed to the fleet. The second female pilot, not expressly identified in CMR’s criticisms, subsequently sued CMR and Elaine Donnelly for defamation. The district court for the District of Columbia recently rejected the action. Lohrenz v. Donnelly, 2002 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 15261 (D.D.C. Aug. 16, 2002). Judge Royce Lamberth held that defendants investigated the facts and had a First Amendment right to speak as they did. The court found the plaintiff, Ms. Carey Lohrenz, to be a "limited purpose public figure." Judge Lamberth noted that the "debate about the role of women in the military, and plaintiff Lohrenz in particular, received both local and national media attention. Plaintiff Lohrenz was named, quoted, and pictured in print and television media outlets." The court rightly observed that the First Amendment is very protective of speech about public figures. A plaintiff who is a public figure must prove actual malice by the speaker in order to recover damages. Ms. Lohrenz could not make this showing, Judge Lamberth found. He held that any opposition by defendants to women in combat is not indicative of the actual malice necessary to recover for defamation. Defendants had based their critique on a letter from Lt. Patrick Jerome "Pipper" Burns, who "represented that he had been one of Lt. Hultgreen’s and plaintiff’s instructors." In the letter, Burns stated that "he believed that Lt. Hultgreen had been permitted to advance where male pilots would not" and he "described plaintiff Lohrenz’s flight training history on the F-14 with a similar level of detail, and gave his opinion that she was not a qualified F-14 pilot."