Court Monitor • Oct 27, 2002

Court Rejects Bilingual Ed

Text Reader

Bilingual Education has lost again in California. The Ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled that "[w]hile bilingual education has obvious racial implications, the record establishes neither that racial discrimination was the impetus of bilingual education, nor that racial animus motivated the passage of Proposition 227." Valerie v. Davis, 2002 U.S. App. LEXIS 20956, (9th Cir. October 7, 2002). Bilingual education was California's solution for schooling its large immigrant population. Non-English-speaking children were taught for years in their own language, rather than immersing them in English. The predictable result was that many of them never learned English. Many deplored this two-tiered system and how it prevented children from learning to speak and write English. As adults they were relegated to low-paying jobs, unable to participate in mainstream American activities. American laws and regulations are promulgated in English, and English is a prerequisite to rising up the economic ladder. Both political parties like bilingual education: Democrats because it fosters dependent voting blocs, and Republicans because low-skilled immigrants provide a steady flow of cheap labor for business. Proposition 227 anticipated political attempts to overturn it, and thus set a high requirement of 2/3rds approval by the legislature and signature by the Governor for any changes. Computer magnate Ron Unz, a supporter of immigration, sought to end this situation by eliminating bilingual education in California public schools. He co-authored Proposition 227, which stated that "the government and the public schools of California have a moral obligation and a constitutional duty to provide all of California's children . . . with the skills necessary to become productive members of our society, and of these skills, literacy in the English language is among the most important." Proposition 227 requires "structured English immersion," in which children are "taught English by being taught in English." The immersion system was defined as "an English language acquisition process for young children in which nearly all classroom instruction is in English, but with a curriculum and presentation designed for children who are learning the language." This enables children to develop early English proficiency. Waivers are available to exempt students from the requirement if there is a need and parental consent. Most parents want their children to be taught English. California voters spoke loud and clear on June 2, 1998 in approving Proposition 227 by a stunning 61% to 39%. Supporters of bilingual education went to court the very next day in the hope a judge would overturn Proposition 227. Their main argument was based on the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which says that no state shall abridge "the equal protection of the laws." This Equal Protection Clause is a favorite of litigants seeking to overturn laws that might affect certain groups more than others. Plaintiffs argued that Proposition 227 infringed on local autonomy and was an unconstitutional infringement on the educational rights of minorities. Meanwhile, the test scores of the first year without bilingual ed showed dramatic improvement. Parents cheered when the U.S. Court of Appeals held that the bilingual issue is "a neutral one, about which system will provide children with the best education to enable them to function as American citizens and enjoy the opportunities and privileges of life in the United States."