Court Monitor • Nov 17, 2002

Equal Rights for Abortions?

Text Reader

The term "equality" can become a wolf in sheep's clothing, when misused. The American people are right to oppose, for example, equality for illegal immigrants, same-sex marriage, and drafting women. Yet the pressure for mindless equality continues, and is now being applied to expand abortion funding. Abortionists argue that if a state program for the poor pays for any abortions, then it must fund all abortions for indigents in the name of health. On Oct. 22, the Arizona Supreme Court agreed by a 3-2 margin. (Simat Corp. v. Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System, 2002 Ariz. LEXIS 180, Oct. 22, 2002). It invoked "equal" 14 times in ordering broad taxpayer funding of abortions. The issue was not whether poor women may obtain abortions – they can – but whether taxpayers must foot the bill. Some politicians embrace exceptions to their stand against abortion, typically for rape, incest, or endangerment of the life of the mother. Their argument is often that these cases are a tiny percentage of overall abortions and not worth fighting over. But the Arizona Supreme Court seized on these exceptions to Arizona's general prohibition against abortion funding. Enacted in 1980, the law limits abortion funding to cases of endangerment to the life of the mother, and federal law has since extended funding to cases of rape or incest. (A.R.S. § 35-196.02) If any indigent Arizonan meets one of those criteria, then she has a statutory right to a taxpayer-funded abortion regardless of her color or creed. There is nothing discriminatory about Arizona's funding policy, and "equality" has no application. Yet the Arizona Supreme Court held otherwise, demonstrating how exceptions to the pro-life position undermine it. The Court decided that equality and non-discrimination require the state to broaden its funding beyond those categories simply because it chose to fund some abortions. Decades ago, the Supreme Court held 5-4 in Harris v. McRae that there is no constitutional requirement for taxpayer-funded abortions. (448 U.S. 297, 1980) State legislatures remain free to make their own decisions about this controversial issue. The Arizona Law was on the books for 19 years before the abortionists challenged it and the activist judges rewrote it. Justice Rebecca White Berch wrote a powerful dissent, joined by Chief Justice Charles Jones. Justice Berch stated that the Court improperly acted as a super-legislature, modifying the statute at whim.