Rarely before, if ever, has a court enjoined the broad investigatory power of the United States. Federal courts typically defend and broaden federal law enforcement authority, rather than limit it.
In an unusual lawsuit arising in California, Carter- and Reagan-appointed judges held against the Department of justice in a case concerning drugs, federalism, the First Amendment and even the Commerce Clause. Conant v. McCaffrey, 309 F. 3d 629 (9th Cir. Oct. 29, 2002).
The federal government frequently prosecutes drug trafficking, but California and other states have passed referenda legalizing marijuana for purportedly medical purposes. If a person is ill and a doctor recommends smoking pot, then Californians are free to do so.
But the federal government retains the general power to limit the prescription-writing authority of doctors. Under the Controlled Substances Act of 1970, doctors need a license from the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) to prescribe common drugs such as morphine and codeine.
Accordingly, when California legalized medical marijuana in 1996, the Clinton Administration responded with a warning that doctors who "intentionally provide their patients with oral or written statements in order to enable them to obtain controlled substances in violation of federal law ... risk revocation of their DEA prescription authority."
In a subsequent legal challenge, the Clinton Administration attorneys boldly stipulated that a "reasonable physician would have a genuine fear of losing his or her DEA registration to dispense controlled substances if that physician were to recommend marijuana to his or her patients." Good for scaring doctors, perhaps, but that stipulation was also an admission of a chilling effect on speech.
The district court responded by enjoining the government from taking action against a doctor "merely because the doctor makes a recommendation for the use of medical marijuana based on a sincere medical judgment." The injunction applied "whether or not the doctor anticipates that the patient will, in turn, use his or her recommendation to obtain marijuana in violation of federal law." Conant v. McCaffrey, 2000 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 13024, *48 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 7, 2000).
The federal government appealed, but the Court of Appeals affirmed the injunction.
States, the court observed, traditionally regulate medicine. Reagan-appointed Judge Alex Kozinski went even one step further in suggesting that the Commerce Clause, the basis for most federal regulation, does not extend to "medical marijuana, when grown locally for personal consumption."
He noted that the Supreme Court itself, in an opinion written by Justice Thomas, reserved "whether the Controlled Substances Act [which bans many drugs] exceeds Congress' power under the Commerce Clause." United States v. Oakland Cannabis Buyers' Coop., 532 U.S. 483, 495 n.7 (2001).
For the two Carter-appointed judges, who wrote the majority opinion in the Conant case, the First Amendment was decisive. "If the First Amendment means anything, it means that regulating speech [between doctors and patients] must be a last - not first - resort."