Court Monitor • Feb 20, 2002

State ERAs Prove Their Mischief

Text Reader

The last question at the historic Carter-Reagan Presidential debate concerned the so-called federal Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). Reagan opposed it, Carter supported it. Reagan was elected in November 1980, and ERA died on June 30, 1982. Meanwhile, a few states adopted state ERAs, and state court decisions interpreting them reveal some of the mischief that a federal ERA could have caused. Texas voters snuck its version of ERA in with racial equality in a state constitutional amendment passed on Nov. 7, 1972: "Equality under the law shall not be denied or abridged because of sex, race, color, creed or national origin." A Texas appellate court used its state ERA to order taxpayer funding of abortions, despite the opposition of the public and its elected legislature. Low-Income Women of Texas v. Bost, 38 S.W.3d 689 (Tex. App. Austin 2000). Justice Bea Ann Smith, writing for the court, held that "ERA does not yield except to compelling state interests." She cited another Texas decision, later overruled, which had used Texas's state ERA in favor of homosexual rights. The Texas Court rejected the state's implicit adoption of the Henry Hyde Amendment (which prohibits federal taxpayer-funded abortions) because it somehow "effects an impermissible form of sex discrimination against pregnant women." This decision is currently on appeal to the Texas Supreme Court (petition for review granted by the Texas Supreme Court on Aug. 23, 2001). Texas is only the latest of several state courts to adopt the feminist argument that denying funding for abortions is sex discrimination within the meaning of ERA. A unanimous decision of the Supreme Court of New Mexico held that New Mexico's state ERA requires the state to pay for elective abortions under the Medicaid program. N.M. Right to Choose/NARAL v. Johnson, 975 P.2d 841 (1998) In Arizona, which does not have a state ERA, a state appellate court reached the opposite conclusion, reversing a trial court order that the state must fund abortions. Simat Corp. v. State Health Care Cost Containment Sys., 200 Ariz. 506, 29 P.3d 281 (Ariz. Ct. App. 2001) The appellate court held that "the Arizona Constitution [did not intend] the right to privacy under our constitution to create a right of Arizona citizens to subsidized abortions to which they are not entitled under the United States Constitution." An Arkansas trial court applied its state ERA in a manner that could justify same-sex marriage. Picado v. Jegley, No. CV-99-7048 (Ark. Cir. Ct. Mar. 23, 2001) The court accepted the argument that a statute which "is legal when performed by members of the opposite sex, but illegal when performed by members of the same sex" violates the Arkansas ERA. After the Hawaii Supreme Court ruled that the denial of marriage licenses to same-sex couples was sex discrimination and unconstitutional under Hawaii's state ERA (Baehr v. Lewin 852 P.2d 44 (1993)), Hawaii voters had to pass a new constitutional amendment carving the marriage exemption out of the state ERA and granting the legislature "the power to reserve marriage to opposite-sex couples." Maryland is one of the most active states in apply-ing its state ERA. It invalidated a lawsuit over adul-tery because the law "provides different benefits for and imposes different burdens upon its citizens based solely upon their sex. Such a result violates the ERA." Cline v. Ansell, 287 Md. 585, 414 A.2d 929 (Ct. App. 1980) The Maryland court quoted approvingly another decision, also based on Maryland's ERA, that the "[s]ex of the parent in matters of child support cannot be a factor in allocating ... responsibility. Child support awards must be made on a sexless basis." By contrast in Florida, which does not have a state ERA, a state court rejected a challenge to a nudity ordinance that treats men differently from women. Frandsen v. County of Brevard, 2001 Fla. App. Lexis 18763, 26 Fla. L. Weekly D 2962 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 5th Dist. Dec. 14, 2001) "Physical differences between men and women ... are enduring: >The two sexes are not fungible ....' Ballard v. United States, 329 U.S. 187 (1946)." It is noteworthy how the court decisions enforcing state ERAs do nothing to benefit women, which was the alleged purpose of ERA.