The U.S. Supreme Court will hear two cases in this term regarding a law that has been on the books without significant challenge since 1974.
The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) protects the privacy of students and families in their educational records, and ensures their access to such records. Many were surprised when the Supreme Court, after nearly 30 years, accepted its first FERPA dispute in reviewing Falvo v. Owasso Independent School District No. 99-5130. And observers are positively baffled by seeing lightning strike twice: the Court accepted a second FERPA case in the same term. Doe v. Gonzaga Univ., 143 Wn.2d 687, 24 P.3d 390 (2001), cert. granted in part, 2002 U.S. LEXIS 408 (U.S. Jan. 11, 2002).
This case started when hearsay swept through Gonzaga University, a Catholic Jesuit college in the State of Washington, that one student, identified as "John Doe," allegedly date-raped another student, identified as "Jane Doe." Jane Doe herself never filed a complaint, and in videotaped testimony flatly denied the allegation. Jane Doe also testified that a fellow female student had "really blown things out of proportion."
Criticism by that fellow student, overheard by a school official, about the school's handling of date rape complaints, sparked the saga. Apparently anxious to deflate such criticism, the school launched an investigation that involved at least 19 college personnel without a formal complaint from Jane Doe and without talking to John Doe.
John Doe learned of the investigation only months later when the school informed him that he could not obtain a moral character affidavit necessary for him to land a teaching position. A Gonzaga official had also relayed personally identifiable allegations of sexual misconduct by John Doe to a state teaching official, which then became part of a public record.
John Doe sued under state law and FERPA, arguing that Gonzaga should not have repeated those allegations to state officials to the detriment of his job prospects. He won at trial, and again before the Washington State Supreme Court. The case has so far cost the college a $1.1 million judgment and untold legal bills.
The U.S. Supreme Court accepted this case and observers are predicting that it will end all individual FERPA lawsuits, because FERPA only implicitly allows an individual to sue. The facts in this case would make it easy for the Supreme Court to so hold. John Doe would still recover $700,000 under his non-FERPA claims, and many would applaud lifting liability for private schools for violating federal education regulations.
But the bizarre facts of this case make it unsuitable for a broadly applicable ruling. The typical perpetrators of FERPA violations are public not private schools, and parents and public-school students need the protection of FERPA because they lack other remedies.