Court Monitor • Mar 31, 2002

Victory for Western Property Rights

Text Reader

Reagan-appointed Judge Loren Smith of the U.S. Court of Claims issued a brilliant decision in favor of the property rights of ranchers on federal land out West. Hage v. United States, 2002 U.S. Claims LEXIS 20 (Ct. Cl. Jan. 29, 2002). He courageously stood up against the suffocating expansion of federal control over massive amounts of Western lands, and held that the government must compensate a rancher for its interference with his property use. Judge Smith rejected the fiction that agency opinion letters, policy statements, manuals and enforcement guidelines can somehow acquire the force of law without congressional approval. Federal agencies often try to assume new powers and impose regulations simply by saying so, but Judge Smith refused to go along. Plaintiff Hage is a Nevada rancher who was run out of business by the federal government. He was the victim of an overzealous prosecution, based on his employee's clearing some trees for his cattle. Hage was convicted but won on appeal in a prior case. United States v. Seaman, 18 F.3d 649 (1994). The federal Claims Court, which cannot invalidate regulations but can order compensation, addressed Hage's effort to establish his property rights in water, forage and "ditch rights-of-way" on his grazing allotment. He complained about the government impounding his cattle, diverting and using his water, canceling portions of his grazing permit, and allowing non-indigenous elk to consume forage and drink water reserved for his cattle. Judge Smith dug deep into history and geography in siding with Hage on his water-related claims. Judge Smith personally visited many of the streams and ditches at issue, and exhaustively reviewed the applicable statutes and legislative history. Water has always been scarce in Nevada and adjoining states. About the time that Congress facilitated the building of the first intercontinental railroad, it also enacted the 1866 Ditch Right-of-Ways Act to recognize and protect private water rights on the frontier. That Act ensures that successors-in-interest would enjoy the same water rights that their predecessors did. Thus, if Hage could demonstrate that the prior owners of his property accessed the water as he does, then his water rights should be protected. Hage satisfied his burden of proof under the Act, but that mattered little to our regulation-prone government. It essentially argued that water rights are not protected against government interference, and that the Forest Service Manual and federal practice barred Hage's claims. Judge Smith rejected the government's arguments. He held that, if the government's interference with Hage's water rights made them impossible to use, then it must compensate Hage for the loss, the amount to be determined in future proceedings. Judge Smith also noted that the government manual and policy "lack the force of law." 2002 U.S. Claims LEXIS 20, *48 (citing Christensen v. Harris County, 529 U.S. 576 (2000)). Judge Smith poked fun at the government's position that Hage should conform his cattle's drinking habits to new regulations. "The owner cannot make cattle drink; if he built the most expensive pipe conceivable and the most beautiful trough that human ingenuity and skill could produce, for the cattle to drink out of, there would be no way of compelling the cattle to drink out of the trough, instead of out of a puddle made by the overflow from the trough." 2002 U.S. Claims LEXIS 20, *51 (quoting a 1931 Nevada decision). Hage's attorney was ecstatic. "For the first time in history," he commented, "a federal court has defined the balance between the western ranchers' property rights and the government's ability to regulate. This decision is a major step forward for the security of federal land ranchers."