Each year, millions of college students pay mandatory fees to support liberal projects. Usually disguised as innocuous "student activity" charges, they seem small relative to tuition costs, but can total as much as a million dollars annually on a single campus.
Some of this money supports so-called Public Interest Research Groups (PIRG), which advocate more government regulation. In addition, liberal student government committees often use the fees to fund causes so leftwing they would make Al Gore blush.
A few students at the University of Wisconsin, the birthplace of political correctness, sued to stop this practice. They won at the federal appellate level, but then lost before the Supreme Court. Board of Regents v. Southworth, 529 U.S. 217 (2000) In a unanimous judgment, the Supreme Court held that the University of Wisconsin may extract activity fees from students, and that "[i]t is all but inevitable that the fees will result in subsidies to speech which some students find objectionable and offensive to their personal beliefs". Three justices joined a concurrence that emphasized a "constitution-al importance of academic freedom", which they felt should confer broad discretion to the university.
Although the Court ordered a remand to develop further facts in the case, the prospects appeared bleak for the plaintiffs. Few, if any, can lose a unanimous Supreme Court judgment and later recover to prevail in the same litigation.
But buried in the Court's opinion was a powerful principle: the system imposing and spending the fees must be "viewpoint neutral". Plaintiffs had originally stipulated, perhaps ill-advisedly, that the University had adhered to viewpoint neutrality in key respects.
The case was remanded to the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, to a panel that included Reagan-appointee Daniel Manion. The judges were then besieged by amicus briefs from Wisconsin Student PIRG (which received $45,000 in one year) and the Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Campus Center.
The appellate court sent the dispute back to the district court with an order to consider vacating the stipulation about content neutrality. The district court was also to consider whether a student referendum can require students who disagree with projects to fund them, a form of "majority rules". Southworth v. Board of Regents, 2000 U.S. App. LEXIS 15470 (7th Cir. June 23, 2000)
The case remained undecided at that point. The University of Wisconsin moved for rehearing en banc to overturn Judge Manion's panel decision, but not a single judge on the Seventh Circuit voted in favor of the university's request.
That left the district court with the task of re-solving the issues. It observed that in the 2000-2001 school year, a $53.12 fee was imposed on students and distributed to various groups. The court allowed funding of non-expressive activity, but held that "[t]o require University of Wisconsin students to pay a fee to subsidize expressive speech without any protection for the rights of students who object to the funded speech is a violation of the First Amendment". Fry v. Board of Regents, 312 F. Supp. 2d 744 (W.D. Wis. 2000)
District Judge Shabaz voided the parties' stipulation that the program was viewpoint neutral and then enjoined the university from imposing such fees until it "establishes an allocation system that operates in a viewpoint-neutral manner".
The university never did. Three months later, Judge Shabaz rejected the university's proposed alternative and granted judgment for student plaintiffs, allowing them to refuse to pay for the objection-able programs. Fry v. Board of Regents, 2001 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 3346 (W.D. Wis. March 15, 2001)
Although the Supreme Court decided Southworth less than two years ago, it has already been cited by more than 20 other decisions, suggesting that its significance may grow over time.