Most Americans are pro-law enforcement, but when government agents abuse their power they are seldom held accountable. Decades of unaccountability for federal raids on homes may be coming to an end, thanks largely to the courage of one man: Judge Alex Kozinski of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. He was one of President Ronald Reagan's most controversial nominees, being confirmed by a slim margin.
Judge Kozinski has not disappointed his supporters. More libertarian than conservative, he has repeatedly stood up to the government and the establishment.
He was the lead voice of the 6-5 decision allowing Idaho to prosecute FBI Special Agent Lon Horiuchi for killing unarmed Vicki Weaver during the 1992 raid on her home at Ruby Ridge. Judge Kozinski held in favor of free speech on the internet by a pro-life group criticizing abortionists. He was the one who stayed a district court order shutting down Napster, despite enormous pressure from the liberal recording industry.
In a case this year involving a misdirected raid by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (BATF), Judge Kozinski wrote a decision establishing liability for the federal agent in charge. He rejected arguments by the federal government that its agents must be immune from liability for unjustified raids. Ramirez v. Butte-Silver Bow Cty., 2002 U.S. App. LEXIS 3893 (9th Cir. Mar. 13, 2002).
BATF Agent Jeff Groh led an invasion of a ranch in western Montana, purportedly to look for illegal weapons and explosives. Only after searching the premises did Groh give a copy of the search warrant to an owner, Mrs. Ramirez, who was alone in her home at the time. Nothing illegal was found.
The warrant was improper. It failed to specify the items to be seized, an essential requirement for a warrant. Agent Groh admitted that he did not even read the warrant before raiding the ranch.
While there, Agent Groh and his colleagues did far more than look for explosives. They photographed the interior of the home and even recorded the serial numbers of the owners' legal firearms.
The federal government does not like to be held accountable for wrongful actions and rarely is. Sometimes federal agents are promoted after misdeeds, which happened in the case of the botched raid at Ruby Ridge. Attorney General Janet Reno continued in power for nearly eight more years after her deadly raid on Waco, and now she is running for governor of Florida. Most government mistakes, even fatal ones, probably go undisclosed.
Government attorneys argued that BATF Agent Groh should enjoy immunity for his unlawful raid even if it violated the Fourth Amendment rights of the homeowners against unreasonable searches. But the doctrine of "qualified immunity" protects law enforcement officers from liability only if they act reasonably under the circumstances.
It plainly was not reasonable for Groh to raid the ranch based on a grossly defective warrant. "The warrant was ‘so facially deficient ... in failing to particularize the place to be searched or the things to be seized' that, had Groh read it, he could not" reasonably [have] presumed it to be valid," Judge Kozinski wrote, quoting United States v. Leon, 468 U.S. 897, 923 (1984).
The government even tried to argue that Groh cured the warrant's defect by telling Mrs. Ramirez what he was seeking. That is inadequate, the unanimous Court ruled, because only the magistrate could fix it: "The only way Groh could have remedied the defect in the warrant was to ask a magistrate to issue a corrected version."