Court Monitor • May 26, 2002

Illegal Drugs in Public Housing

Text Reader

The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) evicted two grandparents from public housing units based on the apprehension of their two grandsons for smoking marijuana in the parking lot. HUD also evicted another tenant in whose apartment a caregiver and two others were found with cocaine. The tenants argued that they should not be evicted merely because of drug use by others without their knowledge or control. HUD's argument was based on the Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1988, which provides for eviction of public housing tenants if there is "any drug-related criminal activity on or off such premises, engaged in by . . . any member of the tenant's household, or any guest or other person under the tenant's control." 42 U.S.C. § 1437d(l)(6) The district court agreed with the tenants. In a decision written by the brother of Supreme Court Justice Breyer, the court forbade eviction "for drug-related criminal activity that does not occur within the tenant's apartment unit when the tenant did not know of, and had no reason to know of, the drug-related criminal activity." Rucker v. Davis, 1998 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 9345 (N.D. Cal. 1998) HUD appealed to the Ninth Circuit and won the right to evict a tenant for drug use by any member of his household or guests. Then, in a rare move, the Ninth Circuit reheard the case in an en banc session and reinstated the original district court judgment denying HUD the authority to evict. Rucker v. Davis, 237 F.3d 1113 (9th Cir. 2001). By a hefty 7-4 margin, the en banc Court ruled that Congress did not intend to throw people out on the street without a showing of knowledge of wrongdoing. The Court described HUD's action as a "One Strike and You're Out" policy and invalidated it. Then, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously reversed in March, upholding the eviction in HUD v. Rucker, 122 S. Ct. 1230 (2002). The Ninth Circuit is the most reversed of all the federal Circuits, but an 8-0 Supreme Court decision overturning a 7-4 Circuit Court decision is remarkable. In holding for HUD, the Supreme Court emphasized that a "strict liability" approach to drugs "maximizes deterrence and eases enforcement difficulties." The Court found that neither Congress nor the Constitution requires a showing of knowledge of criminal wrongdoing prior to ousting a tenant who harbors drug abusers or dealers. Although criminal convictions cannot be based on guilt by association, loss of government benefits can be, if so legislated by Congress. It is possible that HUD won because the case reached the High Court in the post 9/11 political climate. It meshes perfectly with what might be called the new Bush Law: "Everyone must choose. You're either with the civilized world or you're with the terrorists." So grandparents, now hear this: the rule applies to you, too, because we need you to help us reduce illegal drug use. You must decide which side you are on, and if you're not going to be on our side, don't expect the taxpayers to subsidize your rent.