Justice Thomas’s 90th opinion for the Supreme Court extended the sovereign immunity of the states against federal encroachment. FMC v. South Carolina State Ports Authority. 122 S. Ct. 1864 (May 28, 2002).
South Carolina Maritime Services Inc. had asked the state five times for permission to berth a cruise ship featuring gambling, the M/V Tropic Sea, at state-run port facilities in Charleston. Each time the state denied the request because of its established policy against vessels whose primary purpose is gambling.
Unhappy with rejection, the cruise liner tried another venue: the Federal Maritime Services (FMC). The cruise liner charged discrimination because the state granted berthing space to two Carnival Cruise Lines vessels that allow some gambling.
This forum shopping reopened old wounds. It harkened back to the first instance of federal judicial activism in America, the notorious decision of Chisholm v. Georgia, 2 Dall. 419 (1793). In that case, the young Supreme Court authorized citizens of one state to sue another state in federal court. In the words of an historian, that activist federal decision "fell upon the country with a profound shock." 1 C. Warren, The Supreme Court in United States History 96 (rev. ed. 1926).
Federal power, after all, had been sharply and carefully limited by the framers of the Constitution. The states never abdicated their authority to federal courts.
Congress and the states reacted swiftly to the Chisholm decision, overturning it by the Eleventh Amendment. Support for restoring state sovereignty was overwhelming; the House approved the Eleventh Amendment by 81 to 9 and the Senate by 23 to 2. It took the Court itself over 200 years to admit its own error, but it did so in 1999.
In this South Carolina case, Justice Thomas emphasized that "[d]ual sovereignty is a defining feature of our Nation's constitutional blueprint." 122 S.Ct. at 1870. His splendid decision returned us to the constitutional structure intended by the framers. "States, upon ratification of the Constitution, did not consent to become mere appendages of the Federal Government," Thomas wrote. Id. at 1870. State sovereign immunity bars a federal agency from adjudicating a private party’s complaint against a non-consenting State.
His choice of words was apt, as Justice Thomas has become far more than a "mere appendage" to the conservative wing of the Court that his detractors had predicted. He has emerged as its most influential Justice, rebutting his adversaries with ease while invoking principles such as state sovereignty and free speech to reshape the Court.
Dissenting Justice Breyer argued that the Eleventh Amendment only shields states from "the judicial power of the United States," not from federal administrative power. 122 S. Ct. at 1883. At the time of passage of the Eleventh Amendment, there was no federal administrative power and so the text of the Amendment does not address it. Where, Breyer suggested, are the strict constructionists now?
Justice Thomas was clever in his retort. He declared that "it is ironic that Justice Breyer adopts such a textual approach in defending the conduct of an independent agency that itself lacks any textual basis in the Constitution." 122 S. Ct. at 1871 n.8. Indeed, the ever-growing federal agencies are largely devoid of constitutional basis.