When the Bush Administration opened U.S. borders to an invasion by Mexican trucks, the Ninth Circuit stood up and blew the whistle to stop them.
Until recently, the law has kept foreign trucks out of the United States except for a narrow area north of our southern border. But the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) seeks unfettered travel in the United States by Mexican trucks. One need not be a highway patrolman to recognize the increased risk posed by allowing more 18-wheelers on our highways. Road safety is no better than the condition of the trucks and the quality of their drivers. California estimates that 90% of Mexican trucks were manufactured before 1995, thereby posing safety and pollution risks.
When the Bush Administration issued regulations allowing Mexican trucks to roam throughout our country, unions and others sued, and the State of California filed an amicus curiae brief in support. Public Citizen v. Dept. of Transp., 316 F.3d 1002 (9th Cir. 2003). The legal challenge relied on the lack of a full environmental analysis for the Mexican truck invasion, as required by the amended National Environmental Policy Act of 1969.
Immigration is popular with the Ninth Circuit, but the unions’ cause was too compelling. The court held that NAFTA is subordinate to U.S. domestic law, at least when environmental regulations are at stake.
For political reasons at the time Congress passed NAFTA, it was passed as law rather than ratified as a treaty. The Ninth Circuit ruled: "NAFTA cannot be construed to amend or modify any law of the United States, including any law regarding . . . the protection of human, animal, or plant life or health [or] them protection of the environment." Id. at 1012 (quoting 19 U.S.C. § 3312(a)(2)). That section contains another provision of interest to all who are losing jobs to foreigners: "No provision of [NAFTA] . . . which is inconsistent with any law of the United States shall have effect." 19 U.S.C. § 3312(a)(1).
The three appellate judges unanimously agreed that the Administration had arbitrarily allowed in the Mexican trucks. They noted that over 90% of the comments on the regulations allowing the trucks were in opposition.
The Bush Administration must now assess and publish the environmental impact of the Mexican trucks before attempting again to allow them into our country. The number-one environmental con-sideration should be the potential loss of life that could result from old, overweight and badly-maintained trucks driven long hours by many who cannot read English directions and road signs. The potential for death among smuggled human cargo, over-heating in the back of trucks, should also be addressed.