Court Monitor • Nov 2, 2003

Hang-Up Delays `Do Not Call' Registry

Text Reader

It is annoying: you sit down to dinner, the food is served, and then the telephone rings. It turns out to be the telephone company trying to switch your long distance carrier, or a salesman attempting to sell you a newspaper subscription. Can't something be done to stop this unwanted interruption? The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) thought it had solved the problem by allowing Americans to list their numbers in a "do not call" registry, thereby prohibiting calls to those numbers by commercial telemarketers. By the time the FTC acted, the telemarketing industry had grown to $275 billion in annual revenue. It employs an astounding 5.4 million persons in the United States, reflecting the fact that many people do purchase the goods or services offered to them over the phone. The cost of phone calls has become so cheap that this is a very efficient means of reaching buyers, surpassing many forms of advertisement. Known as "cold-calling," these efforts are essential to many industries. Just prior to every election, candidates now routinely call potential voters with information that could influence their vote. Political calling has become an essential way of overcoming media misinformation and bias, reaching voters directly. Charities, too, rely heavily on telemarketing to reach potential contributors and volunteers. The FTC drew a distinction between commercial telemarketers barred by the registry and charitable and political calling, which were not. The FTC registry also did not cover industries outside of its jurisdiction, like banks, insurance companies and long distance carriers. But the exemption for charity caused a district court judge in Denver to block the registry. Mainstream Marketing Servs., Inc. v. FTC, 2003 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 16807 (D. Co. Sept. 25, 2003). After websites widely posted his contact information, an irate public swamped his office and home phone lines with angry calls. Judge Edward W. Nottingham was probably surprised that his academic application of the First Amendment would generate such a firestorm. His prosaic decision held that government cannot prefer charitable speech over commercial speech and enforce a prohibition against only the latter. Consumers, Judge Nottingham held, are to be respected in their decisions. But the government registry systematically preferred one type of speech over another, and he ruled t hat such content-based distinctions are unconstitutional. Judge Nottingham was the second federal judge to block the "do not call" registry in three days. On September 23rd, Judge Lee R. West enjoined the registry on the grounds that the FTC had acted without authority from Congress. U. S. Security v. FTC, 2003 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 16650 (W.D. Ok. Sept. 23, 2003). But Congress fixed that problem by immediately passing new authorization for the registry, with little dissent. In a record three business days, the House and Senate passed a new statute and President Bush signed it into law. The First Amendment hurdle is not so easily overcome, however. Only time will tell if an appellate court answers the call to declare the registry constitutional.