Court Monitor • Nov 28, 2003

Court Upholds Congressional Limit on Jurisdiction

Text Reader

There is growing demand to limit the jurisdiction of the courts over social issues like recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance, posting of the Ten Commandments, and same-sex marriage. Some, however, insist it would be improper to remove authority from federal courts. A federal judge in Virginia considered this issue in the context of deportation, and held resoundingly in favor of taking away jurisdiction. Hatami v. Ridge, U.S. Dept. of Homeland Security, 270 F. Supp. 2d 763 (E.D. Va. 2003). Judge T. S. Ellis III, denied a challenge to an order to deport an immigrant to Afghanistan. Habib Hatami was a 24-year-old permanent resident alien who had resided in northern Virginia for 14 years. Born in Afghanistan, he immigrated here at the age of 10 along with seven siblings and his mother. On August 13, 2001, Hatami was charged with assault and battery against his wife and with violating a protective order barring him from contacting her. Two months later, he pled guilty and was sentenced to 12 months in jail, six of which were suspended. He had also violated the law on other occasions, including a conviction for credit card fraud (1997), fraudulent use of a birth certificate and driver's license (2000), and three separate convictions for petit larceny (1999 and 2000), according to Judge Ellis. But it was domestic abuse that landed him in the hottest water. A federal law allows deportation of an alien who is convicted of a crime punishable by a sentence of one year or longer; 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2)(A)(i)(II). The Bush Administration initiated proceedings to deport him under this provision. He fought it but lost before an immigration judge, and then lost again on appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). Hatami had the right to appeal to the Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, but elected not to, based on misinformation that the United States does not deport to Afghanistan. In fact we do, and the Department of Homeland Security told Hatami that he would be deported as soon as his passport and travel documents could be obtained from the Embassy of Afghanistan. Hatami then sued in federal court, alleging inadequate counsel in connection with his plea bargain. It is doubtful he would have pled guilty had he realized the result would be deportation to Afghanistan. Hatami sought a stay of the deportation pending his parallel attempt to overturn the state conviction with a state habeas corpus petition. His attempt to block his deportation arrived in the chambers of Judge Ellis. "In its exercise of its constitutional power to limit federal court jurisdiction, Congress ... [passed] a significantly more restrictive scheme" for judicial review of deportation orders. 270 F. Supp. 2d at 766. Judge Ellis noted the debate over congressional power to limit jurisdiction, but held it can do so. "This limitation is quite specific and circumscribed; it bars judicial review of three discrete actions: the Attorney General's decisions (1) to commence proceedings, (2) to adjudicate cases, or (3) to "execute removal orders." Id. at 676 (citing 8 U.S.C. § 1252(g), quotations omitted). The Supreme Court has upheld the power of Congress to take away jurisdiction over deportation matters. Reno v. American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Comm., 525 U.S. 471 (1999). Judge Ellis thus denied the plaintiff's request due to a lack of judicial power to grant relief. He did so even though the request implicated habeas corpus, a right the Constitution expressly protects in Article I, Section 9, Clause 2. This decision leaves no doubt that Congress has the power to withdraw jurisdiction from the courts. The only remaining question is whether Congress has the will to do so for social controversies.