Court Monitor • Dec 21, 2003

Court Orders College to Reinstate Sports Program

Text Reader

One would expect federal judges to have more important responsibilities than telling colleges which teams should be fielded. Nor do courts typically order anyone to affirmatively do anything. A federal court just ordered West Chester University of Pennsylvania to reinstate its women's gymnastics team, provide a coaching staff and fund the team at its prior level. Barrett v. West Chester Univ. of Pennsylvania, 2003 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 21095 (E.D. Pa. Nov. 12, 2003). Remarkably, this reflects an increasingly trend of court control over school sports programs. The basis for federal involvement is the "proportionality test" issued under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972. The Carter and Clinton Administrations mandated that test, which tells colleges to match the percentage of women on sports teams to the percentage of women enrolled in the college. West Chester University of Pennsylvania has an enrollment that is 60.8% women. The proportionality test thereby requires that its sports teams be about 60% female. West Chester University did have a healthy 44.6% participation in intercollegiate athletics by its female students, but that was 16% shy of its quota. So it decided to eliminate the men's lacrosse and women's gymnastic teams to reduce the gap. Like many colleges, West Chester University is eliminating men's teams and adding large-squad women's teams to meet proportionality targets. It sought to replace women's gymnastics, which typically has a small squad, with women's golf, which can accommodate a large squad. But more women are traditionally interested in gymnastics than golf, and more men are interested in intercollegiate sports than women. Mindless numeric goals have replaced common sense, and the college failed to meet its quota. That shifted the burden of proof to the college to prove that it was increasing opportunities for women in sports in other ways. West Chester University did create a women's soccer team about ten years ago, but the court found that to be an insufficient increase. Colleges are also supposedly allowed to demonstrate compliance with Title IX by showing that they "fully and effectively accommodated" the needs of the under-represented gender. Surveys are the most obvious way of satisfying this requirement. In 1999, the college surveyed its 1,200 students about interest in sports and attained a high level of response: 39%. That is more than ten times higher in rate of response than most polls, such as political ones. Yet the court disregarded the survey, declaring that 39% response was insufficient to be an accurate indicator of student interests. The court further held that students could sue for intentional discrimination when a team is eliminated. In sealing the college's fate, the court cited an internal college document predicting that it was "in jeopardy of civil litigation and/or investigation by the Office of Civil Rights." The court ordered the college to reinstate its women's gymnastics team with full funding. The men's lacrosse team, also terminated, was not so fortunate.