For seven years, litigation has raged against the Center for Military Readiness. CMR had published a special report on double standards in naval aviation, focusing on the first two women combat pilots, Lts. Kara Hultgreen and Carey Dunai Lohrenz. In August 1994, both were assigned to the U.S.S. Abraham Lincoln aircraft carrier touring the Pacific Ocean. Two months later, Lt. Hultgreen died while unsuccessfully attempting to land an F-14 on the carrier during a routine training exercise.
Landing an airplane on a carrier is one of the most difficult tasks in all of the military and should be assigned only to the most qualified. Lt. Patrick Jerome Burns, who had briefly instructed both women pilots concerning the F-14, described the placement of women pilots into combat aircraft as "politically driven." CMR and Lt. Burns wrote that "Navy policy on the integration of women into fleet F-14 squadrons is, thus far, an abject failure."
After Lt. Hultgreen's death, CMR questioned the policy in a letter to the late Senator Strom Thurmond, then Chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee. CMR also published a subsequent report, in both instances referring to Lt. Lohrenz only as "Pilot B."
On April 24, 1996, Lt. Lohrenz sued for defamation over these two publications and a speech by CMR President Elaine Donnelly at the Army-Navy Club in Washington, D.C. Lt. Lohrenz later added a claim concerning a subsequent CMR press release.
On Aug. 16, 2002, the lawsuit was dismissed, but Lt. Lohrenz appealed to the D.C. Circuit. On Dec. 12, Judge Judith Rogers issued a splendid decision in favor of free speech. Joined by two other judges, she completely affirmed the summary judgment in favor of CMR and Elaine Donnelly. Lohrenz v. Donnelly, 2003 U.S. App. LEXIS 24949 (D.C. Cir. 2003).
The case turned on whether Lt. Lohrenz was a "limited-purpose public figure," who must prove actual malice in order to recover for defamation. Given that she had received media attention when she was first assigned to be combat pilot and then later appeared on "60 Minutes" in April 1998, the conclusion that she was a limited-purpose public figure was inescapable.
The court found that her mere act of choosing combat aircraft when there was a "controversy about women in combat" was sufficient to make her a public figure with respect to the controversy. She thereby had "special prominence" in the debate, and also had access to the media to defend herself against any criticisms.
Judge Rogers was admirably skeptical of remarks by others in the military in defense of Lt. Lohrenz. She noted that Admiral Bien claimed that "no instructor interviewed had stated that Lt. Lohrenz and Lt. Hultgreen were unsafe to fly, yet Donnelly knew that Lt. Burns had been interviewed and claimed that he had said precisely that to Admiral Bien." The court disposed of Lt. Lohrenz's claim that Donnelly should have obtained Lohrenz's full performance records before commenting on the matter, even though access to those records requires her consent. "Donnelly and CMR thus were not required to remain silent until the day Lt. Lohrenz agreed to disclose her confidential training records to them."
After seven years of litigation and $600,000 in legal bills, the case ends in total victory for CMR.