Court Monitor • Dec 7, 2003

Ninth Circuit Bypasses Jurisdication Limit

Text Reader

The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit blocked a deportation by invoking the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), a law passed in 1994 during the Clinton Administration. Few realized that VAWA could impact immigration. It was packaged and sold to the American public as protection against domestic violence between men and women. Nor would anyone expect federal courts to be able to invoke VAWA to interfere with a deportation order, because in 1996 Congress removed power from courts over discretionary decisions to deport non-citizens. That power was given entirely to the Department of Justice, and more recently transferred to the Department of Homeland Security. But the Ninth Circuit demonstrated how clever it can be in reclaiming its power. It invalidated an effort by Attorney General John Ashcroft to deport Laura Luis Hernandez back to Mexico. Hernandez v. Ashcroft, 345 F.3d 824 (9th Cir. Oct. 7, 2003). Ms. Hernandez had been living "without legal status" in the United States, and both an immigration judge and the Board of Immigration Appeals ordered her to return to Mexico. However, her counsel and amici curiae briefs by the National Immigration Project, NOW Legal Defense and Education Fund, and Family Violence Prevention Fund persuaded the Ninth Circuit to interfere. VAWA contained a little-discussed provision to protect immigrants who were victims of domestic violence in this country, though it makes no sense to keep someone here for that reason. Later, the Republican Congress quietly expanded this provision to prevent deportation of an alien who "has been battered or subjected to extreme cruelty by a spouse or parent" regardless of where in the world the abuse occurred. 8 U.S.C. § 1229b(b)(2)(A)(i). Ms. Hernandez alleged abuse by her Mexican ex-husband in Mexico, at a time when the statute did not protect against foreign conduct. In order to apply VAWA, the Ninth Circuit expanded the concept of spousal abuse so broadly that it found her to have been subject to the abuse in the United States anyway. But how could the Ninth Circuit have jurisdiction over this case in light of the congressional removal? Earlier, the appellate court had agreed it lacked power to interfere with the deportation of an alien when he alleges "extreme hardship" would result from it. Kalaw v. INS, 133 F.3d 1147, 1152 (9th Cir. 1997). This time the Ninth Circuit held the opposite. It declared that an allegation of "extreme cruelty" by an ex-spouse could stop a deportation, even when the spouses are separated, and that courts do have power to decide these matters. Moreover, what constitutes "extreme cruelty" is defined broadly to include acts that are not even violent but are somehow linked to an overall pattern of violence. What began as a routine attempt in 1995 to return a Mexican citizen to Mexico has ended with a shift in power from the Department of Homeland Security to the federal courts. This ruling drives a gaping hole in the efforts by Ashcroft to control immigration and enforce the law.