Court Monitor • Mar 23, 2003

Should Women be Drafted?

Text Reader

Five Massachusetts students have filed a lawsuit challenging the federal law that requires 18-year-old men but not women to register for possible military service. The lawsuit claims that this requirement is sex discrimination. Meanwhile, Rep. Charles Rangel (D-NY) has introduced legislation (H.R. 163) to institute the military draft and, for the first time, to draft women equally with men. The prospective drafting of women was a hot topic during the ten years that the proposed federal Equal Rights Amendment was debated across the country, 1972 to 1982, and was a principal reason why ERA was defeated. ERA advocates believed that it would help the stalled ratification process if they could make women subject to draft registration in the absence of ERA. ERA advocates persuaded President Jimmy Carter to call for the draft registration of men and women in 1980, but then-Speaker Tip O'Neill told him that proposal was dead-on-arrival in Congress. ERA advocates then tried to get the federal courts to require women to be registered for the draft under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. In Rostker v. Goldberg, 453 U.S. 57 (1981), the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of an all-male draft. Conventional wisdom assumed that the result would have been the reverse if ERA had been ratified, which it never was. Perhaps the Court took unofficial notice of a published report that some Members of Congress were poised to remove the Court's jurisdiction over military matters if it dared to invalidate all-male conscription. One rationale for the Rostker decision was the Court's traditional deference to Congress, the President and the military on military matters, shown most recently in declining Michael New's appeal regarding his refusal to wear a United Nations uniform. The Court's other rationale for the Rostker decision is more tenuous today. In 1981, women were completely barred from combat duty, in some areas by law and in some by military regulations. Since the real purpose of a military draft is for assignment to combat duty, the Court ruled in Rostker: "Men and women, because of the combat restrictions on women, are simply not similarly situated for purposes of a draft or registration for a draft." The situation is very different in the post-Clinton military. Eight years of feminist influence in the Clinton Administration have resulted in women assigned to many close-combat and combat-related jobs. It is difficult to see our elected representatives voting to draft women, and judicial activism should never presume to go that far. If it does, Congress should use its constitutional power to limit federal court jurisdiction. When America rejected the Equal Rights Amendment, the people spoke loud and clear against a mindless sameness of treatment of men and women.