Court Monitor • Apr 14, 2003

Forced Drugging of Citizens?

Text Reader

Dr. Charles Thomas Sell has been held for over five years, including a year and a half in solitary confinement, at one of the most brutal federal prisons in the country. Is he a war criminal? Murderer? Terrorist? Kidnapper? He is none of those. In fact, he has never even been convicted of a crime. He is the casualty of an alarming new federal power being used against Americans. It entails injecting mind-altering drugs into citizens, even though presumed to be innocent of any wrongdoing. Dr. Sell ran a small dental practice for the poor that the government claims committed Medicaid billing fraud. He feels he was targeted for speaking out against the Waco raid, where he served as a forensic dentist called to duty on the eve of the deadly finale. Dr. Sell is not a threat to himself or others. The forced drugging is purportedly to render him fit for trial, on charges for which he has already served more than the maximum sentence. While Dr. Sell was awaiting trial for alleged billing fraud, the government took the unusual step of revoking his bond and sending him to jail on new allegations. Ever since, the jailed Dr. Sell has sought a trial, while both the government and his own attorney have been saying it is not possible. The attorneys and prison psychiatrist insist that Dr. Sell is not competent to stand trial, even though he attained a perfect score on a prison mental exam. The government says it should be able to forcibly drug Dr. Sell in order to try him, despite the fact that he has already served more time than he would serve if found guilty. Should the federal government have the power to drug its own citizens who are presumed to be innocent? The Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit held in the affirmative, and the Supreme Court is now reviewing the case. United States v. Sell, 282 F.3d 560 (8th Cir. 2002), cert. granted, 123 S. Ct. 512 (2002). The trend is for many defense attorneys to allege mental defects by their clients, especially those on death row. Courts interpret the Eighth Amendment as forbidding the execution of someone unaware of the punishment and why they are suffering it. The same Eighth Circuit recently decided that a death row prisoner has no right to refuse drugs designed to render him mentally fit for execution. Singleton v. Norris, 319 F.3d 1018 (8th Cir. 2003). By the narrowest of margins (6-5), the Court held that the government can drug someone to kill him, especially when the defendant was refusing medication to escape execution. An appellate judge appointed by President Lyndon Johnson, Judge Heaney, wrote the decision affirming the drugging of Dr. Sell but then dissented in the death penalty case. Judge Heaney thereby allows the drugging of citizens presumed innocent while prohibiting the drugging of those proven guilty.