Court Monitor • Apr 6, 2003

Federal Power Loses a Big One

Text Reader

It is rare that the Supreme Court narrows federal police power, particularly in this era of terrorism. It is even rarer for the High Court to implicitly reverse unanimous opinions of itself and a Court of Appeals in a high-profile case. Such lightning struck twice on Feb. 26, when the Court rejected the view of both the U.S. Solicitor General and a unanimous panel for the Seventh Circuit, which presides over Wisconsin, Illinois and Indiana. In so doing, the Supreme Court refused to apply the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) to abortion protesters, and overturned an injunction against them. Scheidler v. NOW, Inc., 123 S. Ct. 1057 (2003). RICO empowers the federal government to prosecute state crimes of extortion and other instrumentalities of organized crime. Extortion is the offense of threatening people in order to obtain property from them. RICO also gives private individuals the power to sue in federal court based on a pattern of harmful criminal conduct by another. Arguably a stepchild of the old "citizen’s arrest," RICO allows anyone to allege and prove a criminal pattern and to recover damages. In 1986, the National Organization for Women (NOW) attempted to apply RICO against abortion protesters, suing in federal court in Chicago. The district court dismissed the case on the ground that there was no economic motive behind the demonstrations, which it considered an essential requirement of a RICO violation. The Seventh Circuit affirmed the dismissal, and the case went to the Supreme Court. The Clinton Administration intervened on behalf of NOW, arguing that an economic motive is not necessary for RICO violations. The Court unanimously agreed based on a straightforward reading of the RICO statute, and reinstated the case for trial. The anti-abortion protesters subsequently lost, and the court imposed damages and a broad nationwide in-junction against their future activities. The injunction was particularly controversial, because any violation could be considered contempt of court punishable by imprisonment. Federal courts are adamant that even their unconstitutional injunctions must be strictly obeyed. The chilling effect on speech was deafening because of the inherent ambiguity in applying an injunction against demonstrations. Any meaningful political protest, including those like the civil rights protests in the South, suddenly became vulnerable to attack under private application of RICO. This case went up on appeal, this time to a Clinton-appointed judge on the Seventh Circuit, who wrote for a three-judge panel in affirming the injunction and award against the protesters. She rejected objections by groups as diverse as the Catholic Conference of Illinois and the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. Perhaps troubled by the result it created, the Supreme Court accepted this case a second time for review. This time it invalidated such application of RICO and rejected the Administration’s defense of federal power. Because the protesters were not seeking property from the abortionists, they could not be enjoined based on extortion and RICO. The vote was 8-1, a stunningly large margin given the government’s position and the Court’s 9-0 opinion in the opposite direction a few years ago. Left unresolved is whether private citizens will ever be able to obtain federal injunctions based on RICO. In the hands of an activist judiciary, a nationwide injunction at the request of a private interest is susceptible to abuse.