Court Monitor • May 14, 2003

Eliminating Free Speech at College

Text Reader

"Congress shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech." So reads the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, establishing the right to free speech as a cornerstone of our liberty. But free speech is no longer welcome on college campuses. Euphemistically called "harassment codes" by their proponents, school speech codes now prohibit many legitimate statements. Last fall at Harvard, the business school student newspaper ran an editorial cartoon criticizing certain school employees as "incompetent morons." That prompted several top administrators to meet with the editor-in-chief to give him a "verbal warning," interpreted as the first step of a disciplinary procedure under the school's "community standards" code. The editor-in-chief resigned in protest. Yet the school's Dean publicly insisted that describing "members of our community as 'incompetent morons' does not fall within the realm of respectful discourse." Indeed, scores of prominent colleges are now policing decent speech on their campuses. These restraints range from disciplinary procedures against students who challenge political correctness to quarantine-like "free speech zones." At West Virginia University, the campus police prohibited the distribution of literature except in "two designated areas for free speech and assembly." Only vigorous objection by the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) and a lawsuit by the Rutherford Institute forced the school officials to end this censorship. Censorship covers most of the campuses of Appalachian State University (only one free speech zone on its 340-acre campus), Florida State University (charged its own students with trespass for a peaceful protest), Illinois State University (requires prior approval for leafleting and allows only four free speech zones), and the University of Houston (requires approval ten business days in advance for speech in four free speech zones). FIRE recently sued in federal court to stop infringements by Shippensburg University, a public school in Pennsylvania. Shippensburg has speech codes that prohibit and chill a wide variety of political discourse. Shippensburg's Racial and Cultural Diversity program requires students to use nondiscriminatory language "free of the semantics that imply the second-class citizenship of some of its members." The school protects freedom of pursuit of truth and knowledge only if not "inflammatory, demeaning, or harmful toward others." FIRE's lawsuit asserts the constitutional rights of freedom of expression, association and due process, invoking 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Taxpayer-supported Shippensburg violates those fundamental rights with "regulations that limit and prohibit speech without providing any objective guidelines by which Plaintiffs can guide their behavior." It is alarming to base the acceptability of speech on the "subjective emotional experience of the listener," decries the lawsuit. The students seek an injunction restraining enforcement of the speech codes, and also a monetary award. Free speech is not something to be quarantined. Nor should it be held hostage by liberal professors, who hold taxpayer-funded tenure under the guise of academic freedom.