Court Monitor • May 26, 2003

Judicial Activism Defeats VMI...Again

Text Reader

Virginia Military Institute (VMI) is the nation's oldest state-supported military college. Founded in 1839, it has supplied soldiers to every American conflict beginning with the Mexican War. But it cannot seem to win a single battle with our judiciary. For nearly 160 years VMI was all-male, calling and treating its incoming cadets like "rats." Among its many harsh training procedures, VMI deprived its cadets of virtually any privacy. A complaint from outside VMI triggered a lawsuit by the first Bush Administration to force it to become coed. Numerous feminist groups joined the action, and ultimately the Supreme Court (7-1) in a Ruth Bader Ginsburg decision, ordered VMI to admit women along with men. United States v. Virginia, 518 U.S. 515 (1996) Only Justice Scalia dissented, and Justice Thomas recused himself. VMI complied, and probably thought that was the last it would hear from the politically correct police. The wounded, however, are often favorite targets of the predator. VMI's culture fell prey to another legal attack, this time on its daily prayer at supper. Cadets were not required to pray or even to look like they were praying, but were required to stand and be quiet. Two cadets sued, claiming that the dinner prayer violated the Establishment Clause of the Constitution, which applies by virtue of VMI's receipt of state funding. Although VMI is building a private endowment, it is still modest relative to private colleges. No one could claim that VMI required its cadets to pray, but plaintiffs complained they heard the daily prayer. They were, of course, also required to hear things far more provocative than prayer at the military school, so offense could hardly be the real issue. General Josiah Bunting III, VMI's Superintendent at the time, defended by noting the constitutional practice of opening legislative sessions with prayers, as upheld in Marsh v. Chambers, 463 U.S. 783 (1983) (6-3). Similarly, the Naval Academy sponsors prayers before lunch. But on April 28, a three-judge panel of the Fourth Circuit unanimously declared VMI's supper prayer to be unconstitutional. Mellen v. Bunting, 2003 U.S. App. LEXIS 8014 (4th Cir. 2003). This decision is unvarnished judicial activism. The dispute was moot because plaintiffs had already graduated, and the Court conceded it had no basis for enjoining the school. Nor was there any basis for awarding damages to plaintiffs. The Court agreed that General Bunting was protected by qualified immunity as a state official, because he did not violate a clearly established constitutional right known to a reasonable person. Unable to award equitable or monetary relief, the Court had no legitimate grounds for declaring VMI's practice to be unconstitutional. But judicial activism against religion is not easily restrained. One can only imagine what the next legal attack on VMI will be. Perhaps invocation of "cruel and unusual punishment" to end them disciplining of disobedient cadets?