Court Monitor • May 3, 2003

Ninth Circuit Nixes Tax Credit

Text Reader

Federal courts are prohibited from interfering with state taxation in two ways. The Tax Injunction Act removes state tax cases from the jurisdiction of the federal courts, and Supreme Court precedent requires deference to state courts based on federalism. In 1997, Arizona enacted a modest tax credit for school tuition organizations (STOs). This credit allows up to a $500 annual offset in taxes ($625 for married couples) for contributions made to such entities. To qualify as an STO, an organization must spend at least 90% of its revenue on educational scholarships or grants. An STO cannot spend all of its money on one school, nor can it fund any school that discriminates. In 1998, its first full year of operation, STOs received $1.8 million in contributions; 94% of those gifts went to STOs dedicated to supporting only religiously affiliated schools, while 85% of the total went to only three STOs. The next year, 1999, enjoyed a massive increase in contributions. One leading STO alone received $4.5 million in contributions in that year. Opponents of the program challenged it in state court. But the Arizona Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the program in a 3-2 decision, and the U.S. Supreme Court refused to disturb that ruling. Ordinarily, that final judicial determination would preclude further litigation. Moreover, the Tax Injunction Act expressly prohibits interference by federal courts with "the assessment, levy or collection of any tax under state law where a plain, speedy and efficient remedy may be had in the courts of such state." 28 U.S.C. § 1341. But neither statute nor logic can restrain those hostile to religion. Plaintiffs brought yet another lawsuit in federal court, hoping that a liberal federal judge would invalidate the program based on its relation with religiously affiliated schools. The district court held against plaintiffs, citing both the Tax Injunction Act and the principle of judicial comity. Plaintiffs then appealed to the notoriously liberal Ninth Circuit, with a state law school professor arguing for them. They found a three-judge panel consisting entirely of President Jimmy Carter appointees, including the often-overturned Judge Stephen Reinhardt. The Ninth Circuit is the same one that invalidated the Pledge of Allegiance, with Judge Reinhardt providing the swing vote in a 2-1 verdict. In this case the court rendered a 3-0 decision in favor of plaintiffs, reversing the Arizona Supreme Court. The Ninth Circuit decision contradicted both federal law and several U.S. Supreme Court precedents. Winn v. Killian, 307 F.3d 1011 (9th Cir. 2002). Judge Reinhardt emphasized "the federal courts' role as 'guardians of the people's federal rights,'" as though the Arizona Supreme Court is not. Id. 1017 (quoting Mitchum v. Foster, 407 U.S. 225, 242 (1972)). He declared a tax credit to be fundamentally different from the collection of a tax, construing the Tax Injunction Act narrowly to apply only to the latter. "If the STO tax scheme were to be struck down on Establishment Clause grounds, Arizona's ability to raise revenue would not be diminished; to the contrary, it would be enhanced." Id. The court also rejected principles of federalism and comity, and sent the case back to the district court to determine if the tax credit violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Arizona sought rehearing by an en banc sitting of the Ninth Circuit. As with the Pledge of Allegiance case, however, there were insufficient votes to trigger a rehearing. Judges Kleinfeld and O'Scannlain issued a persuasive dissent from the denial of rehearing. They noted that the panel could not cite a single case holding that the Tax Injunction Act should not apply to tax credits. Winn v. Killian, 321 F.3d 911 (9th Cir. 2003). They observed that the Internal Revenue Code and Black's Law Dictionary use the term "assessment" to mean the overall tax owed, including credits and deductions. The Tax Injunction Act expressly bars federal jurisdiction over state tax assessments, but judges opposed to religion will apparently redefine terms at whim when education is at issue.