A fatal car accident on a two-lane highway in 1981 has forced a stop to runaway punitive damages. Unusual facts and an outrageous jury award underlie this change. It all began when Curtis Campbell attempted to pass six vans by driving in the lane of opposing traffic in Cache County, Utah. To avoid a head-on collision, on-coming Todd Ospital swerved onto the highway shoulder and lost control of his car. He died colliding with a vehicle driven by Robert G. Slusher, who was permanently disabled.
Legal action was instituted in state court against Campbell. The insurance carrier, State Farm, refused settlement offers of only $25,000 apiece, which were within the policy limit.
A jury found Campbell 100% at fault and rendered a verdict for $185,849. State Farm initially refused to cover the $135,849 in excess of the policy limit, forcing Campbell to hire his own attorney to appeal it and leaving him exposed to collection.
As the appeal was pending, Campbell struck a clever deal with the representatives of his victims. Campbell agreed to sue State Farm for bad faith in handling the action, and Slusher’s and Ospital’s counsel prosecuted this new action in exchange for 90% of any award to go to Slusher’s and Ospital’s estates.
When Campbell’s appeal of the $185,849 judgment lost, State Farm reversed its position and paid the entire amount. But State Farm still had to defend against Campbell’s action for bad faith, fraud, and intentional infliction of emotional distress for initially refusing to settle and leaving Campbell with all the risk.
In this second action, the Utah trial court admitted as evidence a State Farm internal plan to meet corporate fiscal goals by capping payouts on claims. The verdict was a whopper: $2.6 million in compensatory damages and $145 million in punitive damages, later reduced by the trial court to $1 million and $25 million respectively. The Utah Supreme Court reinstated the $145 million punitive award on appeal, and State Farm took the case to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Enough is enough, a 6-3 Court majority held in tossing out the $145 punitive award. State Farm Mutual Auto. Ins. Co. v. Campbell, 123 S. Ct. 1513 (Apr. 7, 2003). Justice Kennedy declared that there are "well-established constraints on punitive damages."
Specifically, the Court held that punitive dam-ages should almost never be more than a "single-digit ratio" above compensatory damages, and that ratio should approach 1:1 for large compensatory damages as in this case.
The Court capped punitive damages further, holding that they should not be disproportionate to criminal penalties for analogous conduct. It is not entirely clear what constitutional principle justified the Court’s decision. The Court simply declared the award to be an "irrational and arbitrary deprivation of the property of the defendant," invalidating it with a sweeping expansion of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Not since the 1930s has the Court applied the Due Process Clause so broadly in protecting business interests.