Court Monitor • Jun 29, 2003

Unisex Police Claim Another Victim

Text Reader

Diversity is a purported liberal goal except for allowing laws differentiating between the sexes. The unisex police insist that there be no diversity in treatment of gender. All-male (and all-female) clubs, schools and associations are not tolerated by the unisex mantra. Hootie Johnson saw the senselessness of this, and successfully withstood feminist pressure to revamp the Augusta National Golf Club into a coed social club. The latest target in the crosshairs of the gender terminators was not so fortunate. The Fraternal Order of Eagles, which has 1.6 million members worldwide, has been commanded to admit women into its brotherhood. Fraternal Order of Eagles v. Grand Aerie of Fraternal Order of Eagles, 148 Wn.2d 224, 59 P.3d 655 (Sup. Ct. Wash. Dec. 19, 2002). Its activities in the State of Washington harken back even to the early days of its statehood in the 19th century. For over one hundred years, the organization has earnestly advanced social and charitable activities. Its name "fraternal" defines its membership. Like the Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts, Knights of Columbus, and countless other civic organizations, the Fraternal Order of Eagles has objectives that its leaders feel are more easily met without mixing the sexes. The State of Washington, however, has an Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). After the association refused to replace "male" with "person" in its articles of incorporation in order to admit women, a lawsuit began to force the change by judicial fiat. The trial court relied in part on the state ERA in commanding the association to admit women members. The Court of Appeals then courageously reversed that judgment and recognized the freedom of association rights of the private group. The case moved onward to the Supreme Court of the State of Washington. Filing amicus curiae briefs against the fraternal organization were at least eleven liberal women's groups, plus the Washington State Human Rights Commission and the Washington Attorney General. The men in the Fraternal Order of Eagles had never before received so much attention from women. Though flattered, they surely wondered how keen their own wives would be about lengthy meetings and overnight trips by their husbands with unknown women in the future. The statute at issue, the Washington Law Against Discrimination (WLAD), expressly exempts "fraternal organizations" that are "distinctly private." RCW 49.60.040(10). The Washington Supreme Court, however, decided to impose a heavy burden on an association to prove that it qualifies as "distinctly private." The court held that the Fraternal Order did not qualify, even though it provided evidence that it did not advertise or solicit membership at public functions. Adding insult to injury, the court slapped the charitable group with the substantial burden of paying the attorneys' fees of their adversaries. Justice Barbara Madsen concurred by relying on a New Jersey state court decision forcing the Little League to include girl players. That reference to New Jersey was particularly ironic, since it was the New Jersey Supreme Court that required the Boy Scouts to admit openly gay leaders, only to be reversed by the United States Supreme Court. In dissent, Judge Sanders noted how the majority opinion failed to mention that the Supreme Court's Boy Scout decision established freedom of association by private organizations to define and limit membership. Boy Scouts of Am. v. Dale, 530 U.S. 640 (2000) On May 27, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to review this case. So the battle continues between freedom of association and those insisting on a unisex society.