Aggressive feminist enforcement of Title IX has resulted in colleges abolishing 171 wrestling teams, 40% of the nationwide total. Colleges have even been compelled to disband wrestling teams funded entirely by private donations.
The quota system for college sports that Clinton sneaked into Title IX caused this senseless result.
Passed in 1972, Title IX includes a sweeping requirement that "[n]o person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance." 20 U.S.C. § 1681. The law prohibits a finding of discrimination based solely on an imbalance in participation by gender in athletic programs.
An attempt by Senator John Tower to exempt football failed in 1975. In 1979, the Carter Administration issued a three-part interpretation requiring colleges to demonstrate (1) participation by women in sports in proportion to their enrollment, (2) a history of adding women's sports programs, or (3) full accommodation of the athletic interests of female students.
The Reagan Administration put enforcement of the rules on hold pending further study. Then, in 1984, former football star Justice White wrote for the Supreme Court in holding that federal support of a college’s financial aid program does not trigger application of Title IX to its sports programs. Grove City College v. Bell, 465 U.S. 555 (1984).
The Grove City decision freed colleges from federal interference in their sports, until 1987. Then Congress passed, over Reagan's veto, the Civil Rights Restoration Act to subject all college programs, including sports, to federal regulation.
In 1996, the Clinton Administration issued a "clarification" that embraced elimination of male teams to prove compliance. It also required that the number of actual athletes on a team, as opposed to the number of slots, be used to compare proportional participation thereby requiring that for every woman that leaves a team, a male athlete must be cut somewhere else.
A unanimous Supreme Court authorized monetary damages to women plaintiffs, terrorizing private schools with a flood of litigation. Franklin v. Gwinnett County, 503 U.S. 60 (1992). Courts then rejected defenses that women are not as interested in sports as men and that eliminating male teams is reverse discrimination.
Wrestlers are no strangers to adversity, and in 2000 they sued in federal court in the District of Columbia. Organizations of coaches, student-athletes and alumni challenged Clinton's clarification and Carter's original three-part test as contrary to the statute and the Constitution.
Instead of addressing the merits of the dispute, however, the Bush Administration sought dismissal on the procedural technicality that plaintiffs were not the proper parties to sue. The district judge agreed. National Wrestling Coaches Association v. United States Dept. of Educ., 2003 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 9677 (June 11, 2003).
The plaintiffs noted that Marquette University's intercollegiate wrestling program, privately funded since 1993, was terminated due to the Carter and Clinton interpretations. Bucknell University, the site of one of the plaintiff organizations, eliminated its wrestling program beginning in 2002-03 even though private funding was available for that program also.
Yet the court held that the elimination of these men's programs has no apparent connection to Title IX, and that perhaps the schools would have done away with these longstanding teams anyway. Citing an amicus brief by the feminist National Women's Law Center, the court concluded that "men's sports such as wrestling are just as likely to be cut because of disproportionate consumption of resources by other men's sports, such as football and basketball."
Pinned this time, the wrestlers take their appeal to the D.C. Circuit. With a bit of luck, perhaps they can draw former wrestler appellate judge Raymond Randolph for their next bout.