Clinton had been president only six months when a top aide, Deputy White House Counsel Vincent W. Foster Jr., was found shot to death in a desolate national park outside of Washington D.C. A citizen happened upon the body and reported it, and investigators upon arrival took ten Polaroid pictures from various angles.
The violent death of this top government official sparked investigations. Within three weeks, the FBI and Park Police declared the death a suicide, and three subsequent federal investigations repeated that same conclusion. But many issues remained unresolved, such as rug fibers found all over Foster's body (suggesting he had been rolled and dumped) and how one person learned of the death before the body was found in the park. Two reporters wrote books deploring the official findings.
Ken Starr and the Office of Independent Counsel (OIC) took another look as part of their inquiry into Bill Clinton. But one of their top investigators and his assistant resigned in protest over the predetermined direction of the inquiry, which simply parroted the earlier federal reports.
Accuracy in Media sued under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) for release of the photographs to enable review by someone outside of the federal government, but the D.C. Circuit blocked release, invoking the privacy rights of Foster's family.
Then, a determined former attorney for Accuracy in Media, Allan Favish, cleverly filed his own lawsuit for the photographs in California. After losing at the district court level, he appealed to the Ninth Circuit. Reagan-appointed Judge John T. Noonan, a member of the three-judge panel, is fair and fearless, and he ruled in favor of Favish. "To anyone familiar with famous cases in the Old World or in the New, it is a feature of famous cases that they generate controversy, suspicion, and the desire to second guess the authorities," Judge Noonan wrote for the Court. Favish v. Office of Independent Counsel, 217 F.3d 1168, 1173 (9th Cir. 2000).
Judge Noonan found, incredibly, that the district judge had never even looked at the pictures himself. Deciding "without a knowledge of what the photos show would be an exercise in the air," Judge Noonan observed. Indeed, all three prior courts had denied requests for the photographs based on their allegedly graphic and upsetting content, without even viewing them. These courts had simply accepted the government's far-fetched arguments, despite its obvious self-interest in withholding evidence.
The government, for example, insisted that all the photographs were too graphic to release, but Judge Noonan observed that one had been leaked to and published by Time Magazine. Plaintiff Favish merely seeks a high-quality copy of that photo in order to view details.
The government refused to admit that it even had that photograph, until the Ninth Circuit forced an admission by its attorney at oral argument. Nor could the government explain why it withheld for years a copy of a harmless photograph of Foster's glasses, until forced to disclose it by the court.
Favish has even agreed to concealment of any part of the disputed photos that are upsetting. He merely seeks evidence to assess conflicting statements in the OIC's own report, like the observed but unexplained bullet hole in Foster's neck.
The Supreme Court has agreed to review the case.