Chief Justice Rehnquist stunned his conservative admirers by applying the Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 against state governments. Nevada Dept of Human Resourses v. Hibbs, 123 S.Ct. 1972 (May 27, 2003). The Chief Justice’s trademark judicial philosophy had been to defend state sovereignty.
"For over a century now, we have made clear that the Constitution does not provide for federal jurisdiction over suits against nonconsenting States," he started out in familiar fashion. But Rehnquist then proceeded to rule in favor of William Hibbs against his former employer: the State of Nevada.
Mr. Hibbs worked in Nevada’s Welfare Division, and wanted time off to care for his wife as she recovered from neck surgery after a car accident. Nevada granted Mr. Hibbs a full twelve weeks of leave, and even permitted him to take it intermittently as needed over an eight-month period. When Hibbs exhausted his twelve weeks, the State told him to report for work or lose his job. He did not report and the State kept its word, whereupon he sued in federal court.
Nevada's answer was that it never consented to be sued, thus the action should be dismissed under the "clear" principle quoted above. The district court agreed. On appeal to the Ninth Circuit, plaintiff Hibbs found a powerful ally: the United States itself, which intervened on his behalf. The appellate court then reversed the district court and reinstated his lawsuit. Nevada appealed that decision to the Supreme Court.
By then Bush had been elected president, but the Bush Administration continued the Clinton Administration's argument to increase federal power at the expense of the states. The Chief Justice obliged.
Rehnquist's Court held that legislation based on the 14th Amendment can intrude on state sovereignty in ways that commercial legislation could not. "Congress may not abrogate the States' sovereign immunity pursuant to its Article I power over commerce . . . [but] may, however, abrogate States' sovereign immunity through a valid exercise of its § 5 [of the Fourteenth Amendment] power."
A slew of liberals, from the AFL-CIO to the National Women's Law Center to former Representatives Pat Schroeder and Marge Roukema, filed amicus curiae briefs in favor of plaintiff Hibbs. The irony is how feminists demand gender neutrality in areas where women traditionally received preferences, such as leave of absences to care for newborns, leaving women worse off.
Justices Kennedy, Scalia and Thomas were compelling in their dissent. "The Court is unable to show that States have engaged in a pattern of unlawful conduct which warrants the remedy of opening state treasuries to private suits."
Meanwhile, Justices Souter, Breyer and Ginsburg remained defiant in seeking to roll back prior decisions in favor of state power. They concurred in favor of plaintiff Hibbs, but indicated their intention to ignore the Chief Justice's legacy of federalism in the future.
Placed side-by-side with the Bush Administration brief submitted to the Court, the Chief Justice's opinion mirrors that of the President's attorneys. What happened to Bush's campaign promise to adhere to the views of Justices Thomas and Scalia instead?