Court Monitor • Aug 25, 2003

Supreme Court Upholds Library Filters

Text Reader

In one bit of good news near the end of its spring 2003 term, the Supreme Court upheld library filters to screen access to pornography. United States v. American Library Ass'n, 123 S. Ct. 2297 (June 23, 2003). This was a hard-fought victory for Attorney General John Ashcroft. Chief Justice Rehnquist wrote the opinion, joined by Justices O'Connor, Scalia and Thomas. Their views could not command a majority of the Court, but prevailed because Justices Kennedy and Breyer concurred in the outcome. At issue was the Children's Internet Protection Act (CIPA), by which Congress conditioned certain federal funding of libraries on their blocking access by minors to internet pornography. Congress thereby acted pursuant to its power under the Spending Clause. U.S. Const., Art. I, Section 8, Clause 1. Libraries are not required, of course, to accept federal funding. But if they choose to take the money, then the CIPA mandates the filtering of smut from minors. At stake was if and how Congress may place conditions on receipt of its spending. This issue has grown in significance ever since the Bush Administration required schools to allow military recruitment or else forfeit federal funding. A group of libraries, library associations, library patrons, and Web site publishers sued to overturn the CIPA. A three-judge panel held a trial to consider the challenge and then struck down the law. The panel ruled that a library is a public forum and thus Congress could not censor content unless the regulation is narrowly tailored to satisfy a compelling need. Internet filters were deemed too broad to survive this strict scrutiny, in the view of the district court. The Chief Justice, on appeal, held otherwise. He wrote that a library is not a public forum, noting that it does not typically invite the public into its facility to speak to others. "Government has broad discretion to make content-based judgments in deciding what private speech to make available to the public," the Chief Justice decided. 123 S. Ct. at 2304. Libraries need not place pornography on its shelves, so why must it provide such access through its computers? But only three other Justices agreed, insufficient for a majority. The verdict depended on the swing votes of Justices Kennedy and Breyer, who upheld the CIPA for an entirely different, and distressing, reason. They relied on the continued ability of adults to access pornography at libraries. The CIPA permits adults to request disabling of the filters by library staff in order to view indecent material at taxpayer expense. "On the request of an adult user, a librarian will unblock filtered material or disable the Internet software filter without significant delay," Justice Kennedy wrote based on a government representation. 123 S. Ct. at 2309 (Kennedy, J., concurring). For this reason, Justices Kennedy and Breyer agreed to salvage the CIPA.