The Fourteenth Amendment, passed to eradicate racial discrimination by states, mandates that "No state shall ... deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws." This command is the flashpoint in racial disputes over hiring, firing, electing, granting admissions, sentencing, and most other institutional decisions.
Liberals argue that this Amendment allows or even requires the use of racial preferences to increase ethnic diversity in classrooms, legislatures and boardrooms. Conservatives counter that it protects every individual ("any person") against race-based selection, regardless of the purpose.
Enter the University of Michigan, a state school, into this conflict. Its undergraduate admissions procedure assigned an automatic 20-point bonus to minority applicants based solely on race, without considering the background or skills of the applicant.
That constituted a hefty 20% of the total of 100 points needed to guarantee admission. Rejected students not benefitting from this windfall sued, and the Supreme Court invalidated this preference. Gratz v. Bollinger, 156 L. Ed. 2d 257 (June 23, 2003).
Chief Justice Rehnquist penned the opinion for the Court, joined by Justices O’Connor, Kennedy, Scalia and Thomas. Many of them also wrote separately, and Justice Breyer also concurred, extending the majority’s margin to 6-3.
The "automatic distribution of 20 points has the effect of making ‘the factor of race . . . decisive,’" and thereby unconstitutional. The Chief Justice was quoting Justice Powell’s concurrence in the famous case of Regents of Univ. of Cal. v. Bakke, which invalidated quotas but allowed the use of race as a non-decisive factor in admissions. 438 U.S. 265, 317 (1978)
Yet this was a bittersweet victory for those opposing affirmative action, because it allows less overt racial preferences in admissions and, by extension, in business. Then the other shoe fell at the Court when it embraced a quota-like system in the related case of Grutter v. Bollinger, 156 L. Ed. 2d 304 (June 23, 2003).
Justice O’Connor switched sides to write the Grutter decision, joined by liberal Justices Stevens, Souter, Ginsburg and Breyer. The Court affirmed the admissions process at the University of Michigan Law School against a challenge by Barbara Grutter, a white Michigan resident rejected despite having a 3.8 grade point average and an LSAT test score of 161 (high 80s in percentile).
The law school is highly competitive, accepting only 10% of applicants. Ms. Grutter’s LSAT score was apparently not in the top 10% of the nation, but some minority applicants were admitted with lower grades and LSAT scores than Ms. Grutter’s, and the school insisted this was necessary to attain racial diversity in the classroom. In contrast to the undergraduate program, the law school feigned a highly individualized consideration of students, allowing race as but one of many factors.
In dissent, the conservative Justices decried both the factual and legal premises of this ruling. Factually, the data showed that the law school was using a quota-like system: between 1995 and 1998, the percent enrollment by minority students was 13.5%, 13.6%, 13.8% and 13.8%, and it is struthious to pretend this was not a quota.
Never before has racial diversity been an accept-able justification for a discriminatory process. One wonders now if there are any remaining legal protections against outcome-based racial balancing.