Court Monitor • Sep 7, 2003

Ashcroft's Victory Against Terrorism

Text Reader

In the aftermath of 9/11, President Bush issued Executive Order 13,224 to identify certain terrorist organizations as "Specially Designated Global Terrorists," or SDGTs. This order authorized seizure of their property, and interests in property, in the United States. The Holy Land Foundation (HLF) describes itself as "the largest Muslim charity in the United States." In December 2001, the Department of the Treasury designated it as an SDGT and seized its assets. The Bush Administration took this action based on classified information allegedly linking the HLF with a well-known terrorist group in the Middle East. HLF responded by suing in federal court in D.C., asserting violations of its First, Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights. This case became a crucial test for Attorney General John Ashcroft in his fight against terrorism. Would the court find a constitutional right for a religious organization to fundraise, despite an alleged link to terrorism? The district court held in favor of Ashcroft, but HLF appealed to the D.C. Circuit. There it met a three-judge panel composed of appointees of Presidents Reagan and the first Bush: Ginsburg, Sentelle and Henderson. Holy Land Foundation for Relief and Development v. Ashcroft, 333 F.3d 156 (D.C. Cir. June 20, 2003). HLF complained that the government seized its assets and interfered with its humanitarian activities based on classified information to which HLF was denied access. HLF was denied its ability to confront witnesses against it, a right that is guaranteed by the Fifth Amendment to defendants in criminal cases. HLF further asserted that the government had infringed on its First Amendment rights of free speech, association and religion. Campaign contributions, after all, are considered to be free speech, and HLF argued that contributions to it should also be allowed as protected speech. The court flatly rejected all of HLF's arguments, thereby handing Attorney General John Ashcroft a hard-earned victory. The sweeping breadth of this decision ensures that the Constitution cannot be used to safeguard activities related to terrorism. Judge Sentelle, writing for the unanimous court, held that "we hold as other courts have that there is no First Amendment right nor any other constitutional right to support terrorists, and that the record supports no conclusion that the designation or blocking violated any constitutional right of the HLF." However, the evidence against HLF was kept secret, and the district court bypassed normal procedures to rule against HLF early. The appellate court agreed with HLF's objection to the premature dismissal, but held that it "would have made no difference" to give HLF more time in the case. HLF also insisted that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) was violated by preventing HLF from raising money for Islam. "No one on behalf of Holy Land Foundation has forwarded the proposition that the fomenting and spread of terrorism is mandated by the religion of Islam," the court stated in rejecting that argument. Are organizations in the United States actually raising funds for terrorism? Fortunately, this victory by Attorney General Ashcroft sharply reduces that possibility.