Court Monitor • Jan 19, 2004

Supreme Court Enters Public Lands Dispute

Text Reader

Imagine a bird watcher spending all morning hiking through a public wilderness to obtain a glimpse of the rare prothonotary warbler. He finally sees one and approaches it, but then a noisy motorcycle screams through the forest and scares it away. Known as off-road or off-highway vehicles, and referenced by "ORV," they are at front of a battle over use of public lands other than national parks. Environmentalists claim that the ORVs are damaging wildernesses, while others respond that citizens have a recreational right to use such vehicles there. The Sierra Club and its allies sued Gale Norton, the Secretary of the Department of the Interior, to limit ORV use in the massive wildernesses controlled by the federal government. Their core claim is not that ORVs interfere with humans, as in the fictional example above, but rather that the vehicles somehow impair nature itself. The Bureau of Land Management has already curtailed motorized access in many ways. On Sids Mountain in Utah, it closed 19 ORV routes and limited such vehicles to four designated routes. The Bureau has excluded ORVs from many other areas, including wilderness study areas at Moquith Mountain, Parunuweap and Behind the Rocks. But that has not been enough to appease environmental groups hostile to human activity. The district court dismissed their lawsuit. It found a lack of authority to order the agency to do more, given that it has already taken action. While citizens can challenge an abject failure to act by an agency in violation of a statutory duty, courts have typically lacked power to declare agency actions to be insufficient. Those issues are better resolved by the democratic process. The Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, however, reversed the district court and held that courts do have power to review the sufficiency of agency action in this context. Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance v. Norton, 301 F.3d 1217 (10th Cir. 2002). The appellate court rejected rulings of the Fifth and Ninth Circuits to the contrary. The implications of this expansion in federal jurisdiction are enormous. Courts could become super-agencies, micromanaging the countless mundane decisions of the federal bureaucracy. Should motorcycles be allowed to traverse one dirt path in a wilderness, or should they be diverted to a different area? Federal judges have neither the expertise nor, we would hope, the time to spend on these administrative matters. Judge McKay dissented, noting that "the court's opinion has opened the floodgates of litigation for plaintiffs to challenge any mandatory agency obligation regardless of the amount of discretion afforded to the agency in carrying out its obligations." He also criticized the shifting of the burden of proof of jurisdiction from plaintiffs, where it has rested for hundreds of years, to defendants. The Supreme Court evidently heard Judge McKay's cry, and recently granted certiorari. All indications are that the High Court will reign in the expansion of power attempted by its underlings. Why doesn't Congress do likewise?