In one of the most unforgettable commercials ever, a Wendy's customer looks at a competitor's hamburger and barks: "Where's the Beef?" The phrase became so popular that presidential candidate Walter Mondale even invoked it, though with far less success than Wendy's enjoyed. Â
Founded by Dave Thomas, who was raised by humble adoptive parents, Wendy’s used quality beef and clever advertising to compete successfully with McDonald’s and Burger King. Thomas’s was a true rags-to-riches story. He began working at age 12, and left school and family at 15 to live on his own at a YMCA.
Only a year after the Wendy's commercial aired, Congress passed the Beef Promotion and Research Act of 1985. Subsequently, the Administration promulgated the Beef Promotion and Research Order to apply the new statute to the suppliers of beef.
The statute and regulatory order required cattle producers to pay dues to a federally created entity. A portion of those dues funded generic advertisements to promote the sale of beef to the public.
The cattle producers sued, claiming that the beef law violates their rights under the First Amendment by forcing them to pay for ads with which they disagreed. For example, the ads would not emphasize the importance of buying American beef rather than foreign beef. Individual cattle producers may prefer to tout how their beef is untainted by Mad Cow disease, but the federally created entity controlling the ads might want to avoid insulting Canada or England.
The federal district court agreed with the cattle producers, finding the statute and regulation uncon-stitutional. On appeal, the Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed. Livestock Marketing Association v. USDA, 335 F.3d 711 (8th Cir. 2003). Invoking a balancing test preferred by the so-called moderates, the court asked "whether the government’s interest is sufficiently substantial to justify the infringement upon appellees’ First Amendment rights."
The court held that not even a balancing test could justify the statute and regulation. The government’s interest was not substantial enough to compel cattle producers to pay for ads they may not like. The court relied on the landmark Supreme Court decision invalidating the compelled speech of New Hampshire’s "Live Free or Die" motto on all its license plates. Wooley v. Maynard, 430 U.S. 705 (1977). The Wooley court established that "where the State’s interest is to disseminate an ideology, no matter how acceptable to some, such interest cannot outweigh the individual’s First Amendment right to avoid becoming the courier for such message."   Â
The Wooley court established that "where the State's interest is to disseminate an ideology, no matter how acceptable to some, such interest cannot outweigh the individual's First Amendment right to avoid becoming the courier for such message." While cattle producers were not required to carry ads on their cows, the distinction did not matter to the court. It even held the statute and regulation to be invalid for all cattle producers, not only for those who sued. The government has appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court to reinstate the beef law, and the Court has agreed to reconsider this dispute over beef advertising this fall.